| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 24.11.2011 - 14.03.2012 | SMASH Champion (as Dave Finlay) | 111 days | Matches |
| 11.07.2006 - 29.08.2006 | WWE United States Champion | 49 days | Matches |
| 03.07.1993 - 01.10.1998 | CWA Intercontinental Champion (as Fit Finlay) | 1916 days | Matches |
| 04.05.1998 - 14.06.1998 | WCW World Television Champion (as Fit Finlay) | 41 days | Matches |
| 25.11.1995 - 06.07.1996 | CWA Mittelgewicht Champion (4x) (as Fit Finlay) | 224 days | Matches |
| 14.12.1993 - 13.08.1994 | CWA British Commonwealth Champion (as Fit Finlay) | 242 days | Matches |
| 19.12.1992 - xx.xx.1993 | CWA Mittelgewicht Champion (3x) (as Fit Finlay) | ? | Matches |
| 21.12.1991 - 11.07.1992 | CWA Mittelgewicht Champion (2x) (as Fit Finlay) | 203 days | Matches |
| 06.02.1990 - 06.04.1991 | ASW Superslam Champion (as Fit Finlay) | 424 days | Matches |
| 01.09.1990 - 28.09.1990 | CWA Mittelgewicht Champion (as Fit Finlay) | 27 days | Matches |
| 23.06.1990 - 03.08.1990 | CWA Europameisterschaft im Teamkampf Champion (as Dave Finlay; with Marty Jones) | 41 days | Matches |
| 17.09.1987 - 04.07.1989 | British Heavy-Middleweight Champion (3x) (as Fit Finlay) | 656 days | Matches |
| 05.11.1984 - 13.11.1984 | World Mid-Heavyweight Champion (4x) (as Fit Finlay) | 8 days | Matches |
| 08.06.1984 - 26.10.1984 | World Mid-Heavyweight Champion (3x) (as Fit Finlay) | 140 days | Matches |
| 02.11.1983 - 29.05.1984 | World Mid-Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Fit Finlay) | 209 days | Matches |
| xx.02.1984 - 08.02.1984 | British Light Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Dave Finlay) | ? | Matches |
| 24.03.1983 - 26.11.1983 | British Light Heavyweight Champion (as Dave Finlay) | 247 days | Matches |
| 10.05.1983 - 07.06.1983 | World Mid-Heavyweight Champion (as Dave Finlay) | 28 days | Matches |
| 21.12.1982 - 17.02.1983 | British Heavy-Middleweight Champion (2x) (as Fit Finlay) | 58 days | Matches |
| 14.09.1982 - 06.10.1982 | British Heavy-Middleweight Champion (as Fit Finlay) | 22 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| ASW Superslam Championship | 424 days |
| British Heavy-Middleweight Championship (3x) | 736 days |
| British Light Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 247 (+ ?) days |
| CWA British Commonwealth Championship | 242 days |
| CWA Europameisterschaft im Teamkampf Championship | 41 days |
| CWA Intercontinental Championship | 1916 days |
| CWA Mittelgewicht Championship (4x) | 454 (+ ?) days |
| SMASH Championship | 111 days |
| WCW World Television Championship | 41 days |
| World Mid-Heavyweight Championship (4x) | 385 days |
| WWE United States Championship | 49 days |
