| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 24.03.2018 - 14.04.2018 | MCW Heavyweight Champion (4x) | 21 days | Matches |
| 17.02.2018 - 24.02.2018 | MCW Heavyweight Champion (3x) | 7 days | Matches |
| 30.09.2017 - 01.12.2017 | MCW Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Joey Matthews) | 62 days | Matches |
| 12.03.2008 - 16.04.2008 | OVW Television Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 35 days | Matches |
| 08.07.2007 - 26.12.2007 | MCW Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 171 days | Matches |
| 27.12.2005 - 21.05.2006 | WWE Tag Team Champion (3x) (as Mercury; with Nitro as MNM) | 145 days | Matches |
| 25.10.2005 - 13.12.2005 | WWE Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Mercury; with Nitro as MNM) | 49 days | Matches |
| 18.04.2005 - 24.07.2005 | WWE Tag Team Champion (as Mercury; with Nitro as MNM) | 97 days | Matches |
| 11.12.2004 - 26.03.2005 | NYWC Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 105 days | Matches |
| 13.11.2004 - 19.01.2005 | OVW Southern Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Johnny Nitro as MNM) | 67 days | Matches |
| 17.04.2004 - 21.08.2004 | 3PW Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 126 days | Matches |
| 04.10.2003 - 04.10.2003 | UCW Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | <1 day | Matches |
| 06.04.2003 - 20.07.2003 | DCW Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York) | 105 days | Matches |
| 29.01.2003 - 15.05.2003 | MCW Rage Television Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 106 days | Matches |
| 03.11.2001 - 22.05.2002 | MCW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York) | 200 days | Matches |
| 01.12.2001 - 21.04.2002 | VCW Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York) | 141 days | Matches |
| 03.02.2001 - 17.02.2001 | NWA World Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York as The Bad Street Boys) | 14 days | Matches |
| xx.05.1998 - xx.xx.2000 | NCW Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | ? | Matches |
| 17.05.2000 - 02.08.2000 | MCW Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York) | 77 days | Matches |
| xx.xx.1999 - 25.03.2000 | IPWA Light Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Joey Matthews) | ? | Matches |
| 29.01.1999 - xx.10.1999 | OMEGA Light Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Joey Matthews) | ? | Matches |
| 21.05.1999 - 17.06.1999 | MCW Cruiserweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 27 days | Matches |
| 20.05.1999 - 20.05.1999 | SCW Television Champion (as Joey Matthews) | <1 day | Matches |
| 20.12.1998 - 01.04.1999 | SCW Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York) | 102 days | Matches |
| 08.05.1998 - xx.01.1999 | AWC Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | ? | Matches |
| 09.01.1999 - 23.01.1999 | IPWA Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 14 days | Matches |
| 08.05.1998 - xx.xx.1998 | Star Five Unified Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | ? | Matches |
| 20.08.1998 - 21.11.1998 | SCW Light Heavyweight Champion (3x) (as Joey Matthews) | 93 days | Matches |
| 08.05.1998 - 31.07.1998 | SCW Light Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Joey Matthews) | 84 days | Matches |
| 01.05.1998 - 31.07.1998 | OMEGA Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 91 days | Matches |
| 22.11.1997 - 29.01.1998 | SCW Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 68 days | Matches |
| 06.09.1997 - 03.01.1998 | NWA 2000 Light Heavyweight Champion (as Joey Matthews) | 119 days | Matches |
| 23.10.1997 - 13.11.1997 | MEWF Tag Team Champion (as Joey Matthews; with Christian York) | 21 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| 3PW Heavyweight Championship | 126 days |
| AWC Light Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| DCW Tag Team Championship | 105 days |
| IPWA Light Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 14 (+ ?) days |
| MCW Cruiserweight Championship | 27 days |
| MCW Heavyweight Championship (4x) | 261 days |
| MCW Rage Television Championship | 106 days |
| MCW Tag Team Championship (2x) | 277 days |
| MEWF Tag Team Championship | 21 days |
| NCW Light Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| NWA 2000 Light Heavyweight Championship | 119 days |
| NWA World Tag Team Championship | 14 days |
| NYWC Heavyweight Championship | 105 days |
| OMEGA Light Heavyweight Championship (2x) | 91 (+ ?) days |
| OVW Southern Tag Team Championship | 67 days |
| OVW Television Championship | 35 days |
| SCW Light Heavyweight Championship (3x) | 245 days |
| SCW Tag Team Championship | 102 days |
| SCW Television Championship | <1 day |
| Star Five Unified Light Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| UCW Heavyweight Championship | <1 day |
| VCW Tag Team Championship | 141 days |
| WWE World Tag Team Championship (3x) | 291 days |
