| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 14.09.2021 - 04.01.2022 | WWE NXT Champion (2x) | 112 days | Matches |
| 18.07.2018 - 13.03.2019 | WWE NXT Champion | 238 days | Matches |
| 19.11.2016 - 28.01.2017 | WWE NXT Tag Team Champion (with Johnny Gargano as #DIY) | 70 days | Matches |
| 22.11.2015 - 19.12.2015 | UPW Heavyweight Champion | 27 days | Matches |
| xx.xx.2009 - xx.xx.2014 | UFO Cruiserweight Champion | ? | Matches |
| 14.12.2013 - 04.04.2014 | ROH World Television Champion | 111 days | Matches |
| 03.12.2010 - 05.08.2011 | TRP Heavyweight Champion | 245 days | Matches |
| 19.05.2006 - 02.02.2007 | CW Heavyweight Champion (as Thomas Penmanship) | 259 days | Matches |
| 06.08.2005 - 03.02.2006 | CW New England Champion (as Thomas Penmanship) | 181 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| CW Heavyweight Championship | 259 days |
| CW New England Championship | 181 days |
| ROH World Television Championship | 111 days |
| TRP Heavyweight Championship | 245 days |
| UFO Cruiserweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| UPW Heavyweight Championship | 27 days |
| WWE NXT Championship (2x) | 350 days |
| WWE NXT Tag Team Championship | 70 days |
