| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 15.04.2006 |  |
Three Way Dance: Jeto (Shinsuke Z Yamagasa) defeats Frankie Arion and Tommy Penmanship BTW - Event @ Lynn Armory in Lynn, Massachusetts, USA |
| 2 | 18.08.2005 |  |
Four Man Gauntlet: Chase Del Monte defeats Nick Sabre and Robby Morrison and Tommy Penmanship IWF Rampage - Event @ Tab Ramos Center in Aberdeen, New Jersey, USA |
| 3 | 31.07.2005 | |
IWF Junior Heavyweight Title Triple Threat: Sean Royal (c) defeats Tommy Penmanship and Travis Blake IWF Commissioner's Cup Tag Team Tournament - Tag 2 - Event @ IWF Center in West Paterson, New Jersey, USA |
| 4 | 24.06.2005 |  |
CW Tag Team Title: The Logan Brothers (Bryan Logan & Matt Logan) (c) defeat Arch Kincaid & Tommy Penmanship CW - Event @ Polish American Veteran's Club in Lowell, Massachusetts, USA |
| 5 | 25.05.2005 |   |
Todd Hanson defeats Tommy Penmanship NWA New England Tony Rumble Memorial Rumble - Event @ Ringside Entertainment Complex in Everett, Massachusetts, USA |
| 6 | 22.05.2005 | |
IWF Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership 16 Man Battle Royal: Damian Adams defeats Aaron Stride and Anthony Castaldo and Antonio Rivera and Biggie Biggs and Chris Steeler and Dan McGuire and Eddie Johnson and Fred Sampson and Kevin Knight and Robby Morrison and Sean Royal and Shane O'Brien and Tommy Penmanship and Tony Torres and Travis Blake IWF Mayhem - Tag 2 - Event @ IWF Center in West Paterson, New Jersey, USA |
| 7 | 22.05.2005 | |
IWF Junior Heavyweight Title: Sean Royal (c) defeats Tommy Penmanship IWF Mayhem - Tag 2 - Event @ IWF Center in West Paterson, New Jersey, USA |
| 8 | 22.04.2005 | |
Arch Kincaid & Tommy Penmanship defeat Criaturas de la Noche (El ChupaCabra & El Milagro) CW - Event @ Knights of Columbus Hall in Methuen, Massachusetts, USA |
| 9 | 17.04.2005 | |
Fred Sampson, Shane O'Brien & Travis Blake defeat Anthony Castaldo, Robby Morrison & Tommy Penmanship IWF 8th Annual Reckless Abandon - Tag 2 - Event @ IWF Center in West Paterson, New Jersey, USA |
| 10 | 09.04.2005 |  |
ECWA Tag Team Summit #1 Contendership Battle Royal: The Logan Brothers (Bill Logan & Bryan Logan) defeat The Chick Magnets (??? & ???) and Johnny Maxx & Mike Fury and Japanese Pool Boy & Mega and Kodiak Bear & Mr. Ooh La La and The Canadian Superstars (Dave Cole & J-Busta) and The OC Boyz (Aden Chambers & Shawn Patrick) and Mike Kruel & Xavier and Arch Kincaid & Prince Nana and Chase Del Monte & Scotty Charisma and Fred Sampson & Striker and Craig Stratton & Tommy Penmanship (13:12) ECWA 9th Annual Super 8 Tournament - Event @ Greater Newark Boys' & Girls' Club in Newark, Delaware, USA |
| 11 | 01.04.2005 | |
CW Heavyweight Title Tournament Qualifying: Fred Sampson defeats Tommy Penmanship CW - Event @ Polish American Veteran's Club in Lowell, Massachusetts, USA |
| 12 | 26.03.2005 |  |
Three Way Dance: Jim Nastic defeats Craig Stratton and Tommy Penmanship EWA - Event @ Holyoke Turn Verein in Holyoke, Massachusetts, USA |
| 13 | 19.02.2005 | |
Tommy Penmanship defeats Pete Hanover IWF February Fury - Tag 1 - Event @ IWF Center in West Paterson, New Jersey, USA |
