Latest Comments

[2.0] "Not a great experiment. He's just not working, and now that he's gone, he just didn't have it. If he had more chances he might've done something, he just didn't do anything. Best way to describe him, he was like a Ruthless Agression freak who didn't do anything. Loveable guy as a person, wrestler he was pretty bad."

[2.0] "As Wrestler was never the big thing. It is the prototype of the WWE divas. I never revolutionized anything and only made female wrestling back in the USA. Adding scratches or halons. That is all that I hate of the female Wrestljng, I believe it and spread it. It is a pity that it was not until the female revolution, that the women's wrestling was not taken seriously. On the other hand, Moolah was an average wrestler, in the worst case, a mediocre wrestler at the technical level."

[2.0] "An okay worker considering the level he wrestles at but nonetheless an extremely bland wrestler. I've seen him wrestle a handful of times across the Kentucky independent scene, always in or near the main event, and always I'm left feeling like he was one of the worst wrestlers on the card. I don't think it'd be as bad if he didn't insist that it was a work. He wrestles a very boring style, has a boring look, if he can cut a good promo I haven't heard it, but he acts as if it's all on purpose. To "work the marks". I think it's telling that the NWA has routinely been booking the biggest wrestlers out of the area but have steered clear of Jack Vaughn even though he's technically one of the biggest names on the scene. Sucks because he's legit got a good build and a sizable audience; bookers in the area clearly look at him as a draw with his placement on cards. If he put in the work he could probably turn his social media success into some sort of contract in NWA or even TNA if he really committed himself to being a better wrestler. As it stands though, I'd say he's probably the worst highly booked wrestler on the indies today which is saying a lot if you're aware of how bleak the indies have been these past few years."

[2.0] "Knowing his personal medical issues at the time, its really hard for me to make fun of his struggles while he was on TV. The companys at fault for putting him out there when he was dealing with all that."

[2.0] "'Stop. You know nothing. You have drawn 0 dollars. No fan has ever left a show thinking about you. You were lucky to be a juiced up double-lifer "over with the boys" type in an era where you hid in plain sight coasting on others' success. Couldn't hang then, can't get booked now.' -Cody Rhodes, April 2nd 2018"

[2.0] "Hook really needs to build on his character development and storytelling as whenever he's in the squared circle, he's extremely boring with absolutely no charisma and positivity about him. At the moment I don't see him having a promising career in Pro Wrestling unless he gets proper training in his promos and overall wrestling as his capabilities are weak. I don't know why fans cheer for him or say positive things about the Cold Handsome Devil as I don't see any potential within this kid what so ever."

[2.0] "She was nothing more that an old procurer woman (pimp). She was the main reason why lady wrestlers turned into T&A in the 90's and why vinny mac made her into a big overrated deal. Her stage name fits her so well. Plus she was old and ugly looking from the very beginning."

[3.0] "An anti-draw. Ridgeway has a bad look and boring style. Reportedly a very unreliable worker as well."

[3.0] "Most over rated person I've seen in a while. She's not bad per say but she's wrestling only short matches for a bit too long. Other people have progressed to longer matches. She's not cutting good promos it's mostly her switching between English and Spanish... Her arsenal of moves is limited to kicks and rest holds from what I've seen from her. Again she's not bad however she's no where near the 8 rating she has on her. A bunch of thirsty guys who would hate on the divas but she's literally worse than most women from that era. Plus, she's kinda ripping off Kelani Jordan's look with her current hairstyle. Looks exactly like Kelani."

[3.0] "Never seen someone so obsessed with being the diet version of a wrestler. Umaga had a lot going for himself. An innate charisma and a style in the ring all his own which suited him because of how violent and savage it is, one can argue that he is the Anoai families best pure wrestler. Solo doesnt have that going for him and it makes him lesser. He also clearly should be his own man, as shown with his street champion gimmick. He is an okay wrestler but nothing remarkable so his push is something that is proving to be the wrong call, as has been with other wrestlers in this era."

[3.0] "I don't quite understand the hype. I'm not super into Japanese wrestling, but Okada looks like a Japanese clone of Cody Rhodes. He can't talk, which isn't his fault, so he gets a pass there. But he is in AEW, and that's an automatic question mark for me. AEW is obsessed with pleasing a small fringe fanbase. I think that if Okada went to WWE, I might have ranked him higher. But he decided to join the company run by a cokehead, who is currently in damage control mode (if you can even call it that) due to the severe lack of crowds, marketable stars, ticket sales, merch sales, MJF, and CM Punk. I think I need to see Okada wrestle more. because what I've seen has not impressed me, in fact it pissed me off. It looks fake and looks clear that the two opponents are working together, which seems to be a reoccurring theme in AEW."

[3.0] "I'm sick of Japanese wrestling being clearly fake. It ticks me off that its now come to the US. I like Japanese wrestling. Great Muta is an icon, and Takeshita is one of the best from the land of the rising sun in a long time, but Idouchy rubs me the wrong way. I think his matches almost expose the business to an Nth degree, and it's not comedy, its serious. I don't understand it. But that happens. AEW has this really bad habit of catering to fans of clearly fake wrestling and clearly outlaw mudshow bullshit wrestling. The Smarks I'm sure will see this and point and cry like LeBron James, but while WWE flourishes, with some of the best storytelling of all time, and THREE of AEW's top stars (not to mention Andrade, and if the rumors are true MJF), AEW has some of the worst Kevin Dunn level production, and a waning fanbase."

[3.0] "Miz isn't good at anything really. His in ring work is below average to competitors unbelievable, his promos are route and don't do anything to enhance his matches, and besides being a good pertain to do public relations work, had done little to nothing to benefit the business. I think if he would have gotten out of WWE and been allowed to grow as a performer that he could have been simmering, but he never left. Best thing he ever did was the talking snack promo on Danielson, at a time when a match wasn't going to take place."

[3.0] "It's truly beyond me how most people here can give him a high rating. The kid clearly needs a lot of training, I'm not even trying to hate because I think he has a lot of potential, but there's no chance in hell he's anything other than a 3. Can do a very simple suplex, great, but he still moves and wrestles like it's his first time. The kid is green as grass and really needs to be taken off TV and sent away to train, would do him wonders to actually learn how to properly wrestle. Aside from that though, yeah he has a good look and a certain charisma which is very rare for folks as young as him to have."

[3.0] "You know what, I'm just going to come out and say it... I don't get Eddie Kingston. Yeah, he's very good on the mic and quite honestly that alone should really give him a higher raiting, but I just really don't get the whole love for him. His in-ring stuff is just very... eh, average, he doesn't exactly stand out and his actual attire doesn't do him any favours. I never watched his CZW stuff so I can only go off AEW and NJPW, but I haven't been impressed by him at all. I get the hype in regards to his mic work and character, but in-ring he's not great."

[3.0] "Such a generic wrestler. From his days with Zack Ryder as The Major Brothers in WWE you could tell he was never going to really amount to anything special. He seems like a really nice guy though, from his YouTube videos and whatnot he's obviously a big wrestling fan and seems to be very friendly. But yeah, not a great wrestler and his look isn't great. In-ring is just very average, will forever be a jobber and I personally could not take him seriously as a champion or anything other than a jobber. Might be because WWE slapped that onto him, but yeah... can't really rate him anything other than a 3."

[3.0] "Who? I mean come on folks, the guy can flip around like crazy which is just impressive as all hell, but that's literally it. Guy lacks any real wrestling ability, he doesn't have a look that would seperate himself from others, he's not good on the mic, has ZERO muscle or size to him. Very good at doing a flip or two, but that's it. Would be great for WWE Speed because it's only 3 minutes and he can flip all he wants, but aside from that... yeah, not good. Personification of a nothing wrestler who is incredibly athletic, not enough to be anything other than a jobber unless he seriously improves and gains weight."

[3.0] "28.09.2023: Ok, time to come down to earth and do a more believable rating. From the very first appearance of Yuuki in Ice Ribbon, I've noticed how well she manages to find new skills to get out of seemingly hopeless situations. This comedy was entertaining in the beginning and I thought that Yuuki would soon start to show her best side as wrestler. I Waited... Waiting... Kept waiting. And she suddenly announced that she's retiring, ha. Okay, seriously - her comedy was getting tiresome by the second month. She was physically weak, unable to compete a whole match, it was obvious to the naked eye. But Ice Ribbon kept pushing her and even gave her a real belt, Triangle Ribbon belt. From that moment on, it was obvious that her career would not last long. In her eyes there was a certainty about this profession, this business, or rather about her future in it. No more progress was felt and Yuuki naturally ended her career... undefeated. Considering Ice Ribbon's departures over the past few years, Gacha King's departure was taken rather painlessly and I don't think anyone even noticed it. Just like her entire time in Ice Ribbon. 2024 edit: She's back, and what can I say... Future ICExInfinity champion? The way she keeps being pushed, I wouldn't be surprised."

[3.0] "She's in the wrong era, WWE would love her in the Divas Era, but today she doesn't fit in, she's very, very green since her beginning in NXT, she doesn't have charisma, only mic skill maybe (and thats a big maybe)."

[3.0] "Great person, I've never seen anyone say anything bad about her as a person, but as a wrestler? She's not good, not even close to being good."

[3.0] "Great person, I've never seen anyone say anything bad about him as a person, just praise for him, but as a wrestler? he's not good, he's just a little faster and nigerian version of Great Khali, I'm a fan of Omos, but as a person, as a wrestler he's not good."

[3.0] "Bad but interesting gimmick, terrible wrestler, if he didn't eat worms he would be forgotten, the best thing Boogeyman did was a rivalry against Undertaker IN A GAME, that alone says it all."

[3.0] "Too early to say, having teamed up with Bobby Lashley and Street Profits could save her career, but I'm going to analyze her for Hit Row, and like the stable, she had a cringe gimmick, I not only don't like it, I hate it."

[3.0] "Another case of one of the best people in Wrestling but a bad wrestler, I didn't see anyone other than Vince speak ill of him, because of a joke that Vince didn't like because he's a bore, he suspended Titus, but in the ring Titus O' Neil is not good, the best thing he did its the Titus World Slide."

[3.0] "He's the sort of wrestler that will be in a match where he opponents works a body parts for 6-7 mins, but then not sell that damage at any other point in the match. He also takes huge bumps that make him look good for taking them instead of making his opponent look good for giving them. Whether he wins or loses has no connection to the match he just wrestled. Avoid his matches."

[3.0] "In the same vein as someone like The Miz, or someone "spooky" like The Boogeyman, Bray Wyatt fits exactly in the mold of these WWE wrestlers whose shine is all centered on their characters, yet it gets all fucked once they get to keep up that shine in the ring. And Bray Wyatt has been in the position where he was constantly screwed over by Vince's creative black hole that everyone blamed his horrible matches solely on the booking. And they're aboslutely right on that matter, but that claim also overshadows another thing that never made me enjoy his wrestling: Bray is simply not athletic, he's kinda sloppy, his moveset is not particularly inspired, special mention to his Sister Abigail, one of the worst fucking finishers yet simultaneously the most practical since he can hit it on anyone. There's only so much spider walking and character chicanery he can do in terms of lifting and adding quality to his matches. Speaking of matches, apart from his bout with Daniel Bryan, his matches are either not well-paced, not impressive or riddled with some of the most insane booking you could ever imagine. You could make a case that from 2017 to the rest of his career, Bray Wyatt has had at least 5 matches which I'd consider the worst matches of all time. Even the taped matches which you think would work amazingly for his character, those matches were absolute dogshit. What else could I write about Bray Wyatt. Oh yeah, The Fiend's mask was cool, at least it meant that Tom Savini continued doing cool shit. But that's literally the only thing I could praise about it. I hate it. I hate Bray Wyatt."

[3.0] "In terms of character work and general presentation Mean Mark has managed to maintain an aura that upholds him as a legend of the business, but the actual meat and potatoes of his work are vastly different from the reputation he has garnered. Whilst I absolutely the appreciate the mystique and character of the gimmick, a lot of the presentation of Taker was very weak. Firstly, his promos have never been good, and often only serve to strip away a lot of the mystique that his presentation had worked hard to maintain. Secondly, whilst the persona itself is entertaining in isolation, it's played a significant part in some of the worst wrestling TV ever produced. Kidnappings, crucifixions, the entire Bike Taker run, possessing Justin Roberts, the Big Show disciple run, burying Paul Bearer in cement and the horrendously homophobic angle with Kanyon. Some of this could mabye be forgiven if the in ring work at the end of these angles served as a pallet cleanser, however Taker has played a part in some embarrassinglly bad matches. Taker has a tendency to "brawl" in the most uninteresting way possible, throwing awful punches to fill time and plod around the ring without much purpose or even intensity. This is made all the more infuriating by the fact that he has some amazaing matches in his repetoire with the likes of Angle, Bret & Punk, however the level of effort in those matches are not present in a large majority of his work. This would be true even without the disatrous end of career run he had, embarassing himself in Saudi Arabia in some of the worst matches of the 2010's has only served to further strip away the mystique had managed to cling onto."

[3.0] "All the points here are for his wrestling which has been entertaining enough in his limited spots. Unfortunately he's absolutely appalling and an absolute shill as a commentator. He puts over absolutely everything to such a degree that it's corny and exhausting. I don't doubt he's enjoying himself and plays to that but at this point it's just obnoxious the way he'll get on the table to dance to certain themes, demand Michael Cole acknowledges Roman Reigns, etc. Absolute definition of a jock commentator."

[3.0] "Never liked him as a wrestler and his overall personality just rubbed me the wrong way. He's not the worst wrestler in the world, but man is he boring and leaves a lot to be desired. If he was any good, WWE would've kept him around instead of releasing him over a decade ago. I know he's beloved by people online, but he just doesn't do it for me. Would never be believable as a heel or legitimate wrestler, he's just a bit of a clown who somehow is making a living within the world of professional wrestling."

[3.0] "Ah yes, Ryback, the IWC's lolcow who can't accept he was a flash in the pan. The best way to describe Ryback would be if Goldberg wore Rob Van Dam's singlets and had the ego of The Ultimate Warrior. While I could go over how off the deep end Ryback has gone in real life, I'm not focusing on that since I'm rating the wrestler. Ryback was a below average wrestler who was unsafe in the ring, couldn't cut a promo at all, lacked charisma, only had size and literally can't be carried to good singles matches (CM Punk and John Cena tried)."

[3.0] "So here is the thing he was a pretty decent in ring guy most of his career but also could be very boring. Finally later in his career he found an act that seemed really cool. But a big problem is once you see him do the crazy stuff once that's it's you've seen all he really to offer and the more you see of it the quicker it wears thin. I mean we rip a lot of younger talent for just doin spots to look cool and to me PCO is one of the worst offenders of that I've ever seen. It's the classic all sizzle no steak."

[3.0] "I had a short n sweet review here earlier but it didn't say enough about how much I simply don't like him. His look was cosplay Barry Windham, which was only fine because he was Barry's lil brother. He also was f#ckin UGLY and resembled Ren Hoek (of Ren & Stimpy), he had the ugliest weirdest baby teeth and because of them, his adult lips sagged around their lack of proper form. Also in his early days, he was frail in appearance, and often his body language was unsure of itself. I couldn't stand looking at him! Top all of this with wretchedly bad promo work. His ring work ranged from not very good to surprisingly capable, so that's where some points come from. Later resurfaced in WCW as a West Texas Redneck and at least he finally put on some mass. 2.5"

[3.0] "Rewriting my rating/review and going the math route because that's the fairest way to come up with a number. Started as an inoffensive ring announcer (not commentator) in Houston then for Bill Watts (5). Hideously bad commentator when he first started in the WWF (1). Helped produce my favorite era of Prime Time Wrestling (9). I fast forward through most Brother Love segments but not all (3.5). Liked to book gaga (3). Denial of Jerry Jarrett possibly taking over the WWF for months if not years (0). His Lance Russel gets an eleven (11). Vince's #1 yes man (0). Reo Rodgers (0). I liked his podcast for a while then grew to not care for it whatsoever (4.5). So far we're at a 3.36 which is higher than I rated him before. Who knows what I might put into the equation later but that seems fair for now."

[3.0] "If I'm honest, Karrion never seemed like a great performer to me, it bores me listening to him and seeing him on TV, he has nothing that interests me, I feel sorry for those who trusted him. But for me he is not a great wrestler, not even during his time in TNA, he was able to shine."

[3.0] "Honestly, I don't think this guy is quite as bad as he gets his credit for. He's not good, mind you, at basically anything, but if you need a mid-card monster, he can do the job okay. I really think it was just being saddled with one of the all-time bad gimmicks in the Yetay that killed him. Raven's Flock era Reese was kind of fun as a heater for the group, and I kind of enjoy his "Seven Foot Tall Eddie Edwards" look. A shame he can't wrestle remotely like Eddie Edwards, but hey, he's seven feet tall, he doesn't necessarily have to. That being said, he's light on even the interesting power moves, and the limited promo time he got was absolutely dreadful, so he always had a limited ceiling, but I kind of wish they had given him a slightly better opportunity to show out."

[3.0] "Whoa. Oof. I don't know. I don't know how this guy's rating is as high as it is. Maybe it's unfair of me to rate him off the back of one match, but he opened Judgement 2024 vs Tsubasa Suzuki--a wrestler without a profile on here--and Tsubasa looked like a star next to this guy. Soma's offense was sloppy and lethargic, it genuinely looked like he didn't want to be there, and to be completely shown up by someone that seems to unquestionably enhancement talent seems... uh, troublesome, to say the least. I'll change this if he comes back and impresses me in some other match, but this introduction was extremely sour for me. Great theme music though! EDIT: I have now seen him in four matches and he is consistently the worst worker in all of them. Absolutely don't understand what was going on with him in 16-20 that made people rate him so highly but he absolutely doesn't have it anymore."

[3.0] "Goldberg IS NOT A WRESTLER, he was always limited, but his physique and presence saved him. You could say he was a lump. He really hasn't aged well as a wrestler. His legacy has been very tarnished. And for obvious reasons he was never my favorite wrestler."

[3.0] "It feels like this guy is asleep during every segment and match he's in. He puts in zero effort and when he does he is just very bad. He's a complete nepotism hire since he's Roman Reigns' cousin or something, I hope the WWE stops pushing him. Every time he is on screen it makes me want to stop watching. Giving him a 3 is generous but he isn't an absolute DUD. ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ"

[3.0] "As a wrestler during the Kings of NXT story? He was actually not that bad as a complete novice! But as a commentator, which is his main job dear god, he sucks! The entire discourse over "googling" wrestlers who make surprise appearances doesn't make sense at first blush when you consider that, typically, a promotion's play-by-play announcer (in WWE's case, Michael Cole) will quickly give you a run-down, but then it makes more sense when you consider that typically, WWE's color commentators (e.g. Graves, Booker, JBL) have been so bad you want to mute the TV come 8pm, and Pat really is no exception."

[3.0] "I don't say it's bad. But maybe a run by Japan helps him improve his level. that has been bad since I debut. I have not really seen any improvement. However, this score can change according to the improvement you have or not. I hope it gets better. Because it seems to me that it has a presence. But the ability is missing."

[3.0] "I remember Nostalgia Alicia Fox. But it has not aged well that memory, her skills were always very limited and never managed to highlight. A product that that time. I had nothing out of the Wrestler. However, in his defense he would say that perhaps they could not get their full potential, since they did not mind training the female Wrestlers."

[3.0] "I used to be on the bandwagon supporting the idea that The Fiend was a great character, but I'm glad that I hopped off. I had no reason to ever think that, as Bray Wyatt is one of the weirdest and most overrated guys in a while. People say he can cut a promo, but all he does is passionately shout a bunch of rambling nonsense. Horrible in the ring and had one of the worst matches ever with his Fiend persona in HIAC with Rollins. It doesn't make sense how he can go from surviving 11 curb stomps to losing to a single RKO. He had one of the most hyped returns of 2022, had one bad MOUNTAIN DEW gimmick match, and then leaves for half a year. Anyone who jobs to this fool is set for guaranteed failure (LA Knight is too talented; a rare exception). Triple H never should've brought this goof back. 2ND EDIT: I have erased my first edit from the time of his death. Not a word I wrote in that edit was true. I do not feel nostalgic for his run as a swamp cultist. I certainly did not appreciate him saying that he had the whole world in his hands. Not that I ever said that I was ever amused by that in the first place, however I simply cannot find a way to respect Bray Wyatt even after his death. Everything his character was at any given time was the complete opposite of what I stand for. Now, before anyone asks why I gave the Undertaker a 9, at least the Undertaker specialized in PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING MATCHES rather than budget short horror films, not including the boneyard match, but, cmon, that match was much closer to WRESTLING than the atrocious FIREFLY FUN HOUSE MATCH. Bray Wyatt had absolutely no right to say that he specialized in professional wrestling, since he only focused on having an intriguing character while never truly attempting to improve the quality of his ring skills; I would even argue that they regressed over time. Ultimately, running out of Bray Wyatts work is not enough to make up for the bad quality of the work which we are left with."

[3.0] "The Bray Wyatt/Fiend of women's wrestling. You can see that there is/was something there early in her career but she never really connected and consistently disappointed. Then came the gimmick change which finally did get her to stand out but at the sacrifice of, well, everything else. Kudos to most promoters for cutting their losses and just moving on from her, unfortunately AEW seems committed to making a flat joke the center of their women's division (for the second time actually). It ultimately doesn't matter with how that division is booked but still unfortunate."

[3.0] "He's fine. Nothing interesting or unique about him but he's palatable. His style of in ring work is a dime a dozen these days and as for character work there really isn't any outside of playing into the same underdog match structure over and over. If it were pre 2010 the novelty of his style could've carried him to a higher rating but alas it's the year of our lord 2022 and there are atleast 5 Blake Christians in training at your nearest wrestling school. (edit 4/23/2024) he has now been running a heel character as GCW champ for going on an eternity now and it's gotten so much worse. Blake Christian has gone from unremarkable to downright ass. As compelling as a steel toe boot with all the charisma of one as well."

[4.0] "I admit the personality is there, but her ring work needs work even if she's willing to take high risk so early. The ceiling is low, she hasn't shown too much standout moment, when other women had less time. Could end up just being another face in the division."

[4.0] ""I can't understand why WWE is pushing him. He's too small to be the powerhouse they're trying to make him out to be, yet too sluggish to be anything else. His character's a mess, mimicking Umaga's moves and screaming like a savage when it doesn't fit. It's blatant nepotism; without his wrestling family, he'd be nowhere. Still, I'll give him a 4 for his in-ring ability and potential down the line, given his youth.""

[4.0] ""Shotzi's been a total letdown lately. Her character's cringeworthy, promos are weak, selling's off, and she's botching left and right. Had some potential in the indies and NXT, but now? Not cutting it on the main roster. Seeing her on TV just irks me.""

[4.0] "Big bayou boy who has had a couple of appearances on TV so far. Really not enough available to give him much of a rating as he is only just starting out but there's potential in an odd tag team with Big Body Javi."

[4.0] "I'm very impressed that a man who had more than 20 years of in-ring experience ended up not evolving at all as a professional wrestler, yet he's constantly being the center of the discussion for the most underrated wrestler. And I completely understand the people who have that take. Because he does excel at two particular things, bringing natural heat from the crowd and doing excellent promos. But even that restricts him to a box when he sucks at being a babyface, and even if the "Awesome" catchphrase wasn't all that great to begin with, his attempt at turning "Really? " into a catchphrase is really embarrassing. But the main drawback to Miz's body of work is really subpar, he can't carry a quality match consistently, as the best matches of his career had important contributions from his opponents. Main example would be the 4-way with Owens, Zayn and Cesaro (Claudio Castagnoli), there was nothing about Miz's performance that was stand-out even if he was being the sneaky smarmy WWE-type performer, and the only thing that made this match good was the contributions of the former indy stars who really shined in their own fashion. Here's a better example, his match with Ziggler at No Mercy 2016 is rated very highly in the list of WWE during the 2010's, but what was about the match that was praised? Again it wasn't Miz's performance, despite it being arguably his best one (which is not a compliment, he just happened to have an average performance). He just happened to face a better wrestler in the form of Dolph Ziggler and had the retirement angle and the heel shenanigans that added more stakes to the match. Despite me airing my grievances over The Miz's wrestling abilities, none of what I said are indicative of his personality because he's very much beloved backstage. I'm just disappointed that a guy who isn't so problematic backstage ends up having one of the most overpraised body of work in the history of wrestling."

[4.0] "The Rock had the ability to 'electirfy' the crowd more than any other wrestler besides maybe Stone Cold Steve Austin, Hulk Hogan, Shawn Michaels, Bret Hart and a couple other greats. The Rock's mic skills were unmatchable as he was in a league of his own and he could wrestle with such an intense style that his matches were always entertaining to watch. As a wrestler he delivered great matches and will be widely considered one of the greatest entertainers and in ring performers along with Stone Cold Steve Austin, Bret Hart etc. However as good as he is, he has sort of tainted his legacy as of late. He has shown little respect for the WWE business despite being given nothing but special treatment and he recently forced himself into the Wrestlemania Event with Cody and Roman which he had no business doing. There's also pretty strong reasons to believe that The Rock is using PEDs... It just seems like The Rock can't just live a normal life and is doing whatever he can to get attention from people."

[4.0] "*sigh* Billed as Scott Casey's brother but even when I was a young one I knew they weren't related. How did I know? Scott had fire, loads of charisma, a style of his own, he was COWBOY SCOTT CASEY! This guy *only* had a commendable (but small) body with a handsome face, a decent mustache and flowing locks. He was lukewarm, had almost no charisma, was interchangeable and just didn't have "it". I wanted him to be more, I wanted to like him but he was a disappointment. He's not awful, he's only there. He fills a spot on the card but I'd rather see someone else be in his spot if I'm honest. Guys this size are usually overachievers but he was not. Another thing that hurts is just looking at him, you'd at least expect Jerry Allen work but what you get isn't even close to that level. All of these decades later and I'm still three fourths mad at him for being a nothing all while using the last name of one of my all time tippy top faves. You sir, are NO Cowboy Scott Casey."

[4.0] "honestly, i would rate him much higher if wwe actually gave him more, he was pushed in 2001, even having the most memorable royal rumble elimation of all time, but he is a good wrestler, i dont think he was bad, but not the best."

[4.0] "Oy vey. Dude this guy is like if Bam Bam Bigelow was old, wrinkled, Japanese, had zero agility, could not wrestle and only hit people, and had an earworm theme. In AEW he decided he wanted to go against Jon Moxley, (a guy I used to like mind you), but has turned into a garbageman and garbage wrestler, and the AEW guys ate up the garbage. I'm critical of things like this because I don't like wrestling being tarnished by psychotic fans who see stuff like, light bulbs and thumbtacks and go, "oh thats sick dude.""

[4.0] "Xena definitely looks great, but unfortunately that's where it ends with her. Bland character and personality, her wrestling is subpar, and very unconvincing selling. She looks like she's going through the motions in all of her matches that I've seen. In summary, she looks like a star, but definitely doesn't shine like one."

[4.0] "Few guys have had a downfall like Chris Jericho in the last 2 years. Worse Promos, worse matches, horrible look , horrible storylines. The worst thing that he is doing at the moment is taking momentum during his endless feuds, by just repeating and repeating and taking new stars "Under his wing", leaving them stuck and making them lose their momentum. I was actually inspired to lower my rating because of Hook, this half-feud/half-team is not helping him get on the level of hype when he had the streak, and is relegating him to the MIDCARD. Jericho overall is awesome and one of the best, bit he really needs to retire because no one likes overextended careers. His Overall career is a 9, but his current run is 1 or 2. So 4 points seems enough, but it could be lower if he keeps wrestling as he is doing now"

[4.0] "very obvious hes the type of person who got by when people still believed wrestling was real. cant knock him any less for that as he still had the crowds going seemingly but man he moved incredibly stiff from what ive seen. interesting character work but not enough to watch the matches, maybe hear about him in documentaries is enough"

[4.0] "I used to like him. He had potential and still does. Unfortunately he seems to have learned all the wrong lessons from the House of Torture - or maybe House of Torture just sucks that much - and gotten extremely lazy with his work. You can be bland in the ring if you're charismatic enough to cover for it. You can be uncharismatic if you're great in the ring. But being boring on the stick and boring in the ring is a a one-way ticket to the lower midcard."

[4.0] "This guy is the same height as my grandma, and has an improbably unpronounceable ring name, with very weird ring gear, and a penchant for flippy flopping, and rope decapitation. I'm not a fan to say the least. And to the marks, claiming about Rey Mysterio, I LOVE REY, and he can talk, has a decent build, and can work his ass off, not to mention some of the greatest ring gear of all time, while "EL HIJO DEL VIKINGO" doesn't have any of that. Again, not my cup of tea. It's typical AEW spotfests, I remember Tony "cokehead" Khan's announcement, and saying "EL WHO DEL VIKINGWHO? ""

[4.0] "Johnny Wrestling? More like Johnny Boring. He has ZERO personality. And he doesn't have the in-ring skills that would make up for the lack of ability to talk. Here's another thing, ADAM COLE HAS A BETTER PHYSIQUE THAN JOHNNY BORING. Thats not good. And then here's the kicker, the two people that hate each other more than anyone in the world, Vince "shitstain" Russo, and James E. "Jim" Cornette, agree that Gargano sucks. When the two people that couldn't agree on what to get for dinner agree that you suck, that's quite telling."

[4.0] "How the mighty have fallen. I think she should retire; she had a huge role on a huge show, on a huge platform. twice. Once in WWE, where despite her stature did very well for herself and had a great rivalry with Bayley and again on Disney+, where she starred in the Mandalorian with Pedro Pascal, the late great Carl Weathers, Gina Carano, and Kaitee fucking Sackhoff. She went to Japan, and did absolutely nothing, including the first promo that wanted me to jump off a roof. I think she should stick to Star Wars for now."

[4.0] "I cant stand these morons. more than anyone in AEW, I hate the young cucks. They have ruined the superkick. They are jokes, they attacked their top babyface, and caused him to leave for WWE, due to their politicking, stupidity, and meeting cancelations. They are not cool, they can barely wrestle, and they have zero promo ability. I sincerely hope more people realize how bad these two jokes are. I was livid, when Sting's last match was gonna be against these jackasses, who due to their standing decided to book themselves as top heels. disgusting."

[4.0] "I cant stand these morons. more than anyone in AEW, I hate the young cucks. They have ruined the superkick. They are jokes, they attacked their top babyface, and caused him to leave for WWE, due to their politicking, stupidity, and meeting cancelations. They are not cool, they can barely wrestle, and they have zero promo ability. I sincerely hope more people realize how bad these two jokes are. I was livid, when Sting's last match was gonna be against these jackasses, who due to their standing decided to book themselves as top heels. disgusting."

[4.0] "Seems like a nice guy and all, but he doesn't have "it." Not saying every wrestler needs to have this element of superstar aura but it's very clear what his ceiling is. He's decent in-ring, wouldn't really say I'd be excited to see him on TV or at a show. Will forever be an undercard guy, can turn it into something good if he understands that."

[4.0] "He's not very good, to be honest. Being a big guy and capable of doing a moonsault is great and all, but that's literally all he is. Could really be a big name, but clearly lacks the ability in-ring and on the mic. Has a great look, but again, that's it."

[4.0] "I feel like it's way too early to actually give him anything other than a 4. People were hyping this guy up like crazy, whilst the potential IS there I feel like it's going to take him quite a while before he eventually reaches that point. Good in-ring, needs to work on his actual look though because I think that's holding him back. The whole dancing gimmick is awful, should never have done that because it unfortunately got over. If he was happy being that goofy dancing guy then sure, good for him, but he clearly is capable of being much more than that."

[4.0] "Sasha Banks/Mercedes Mone is somebody who really diverses the wrestling fanbase. You either love her or hate her, there's no real in-between. I'm honestly not a fan, I do not understand the appeal nor the praise she gets for her in-ring ability. She is 100% overrated, whilst she has had some good matches, I feel like her overall presence is just bad. Her mic skills are awful, like beyond awful, actually. Can hear a pin drop whenever she talks, which isn't good. I will admit, her actual attires and whatnot are very good and really make her stand out from a lot of other female wrestlers, but that's literally it. There was a lot of talk about how good she was going to be post-WWE and she really hasn't lived up to any of it."

[4.0] "Man... what happened to this guy? He had SO MUCH POTENTIAL. Was touted as being one of the next big things in pro-wrestling during his indy days as Uhaa Nation. Thought he would finally get that big break when joining WWE, they really tried at first to make him special but he just doesn't have "it." I feel like he peaked very early, and his peak wasn't exactly great or anything, and he has just stagnated ever since. Most people from that NXT class he was in have gone on to surpass him, which if you would've told me that back when he signed with WWE I would've said you were crazy."

[4.0] "I just don't get it. Miro is nothing special. People thought he was going to excel in AEW and the guy has done anything but that. His run in NXT was pretty bad, I still remember that piece of wood he would carry to the ring... pretty stupid, especially in the 2010s. Made a great impact in the 2016 Royal Rumble, his look really differentiated him from everybody else on the roster around that time. However, he just isn't capable of having good matches, he can talk which is a plus but everything else just falls short. His in-ring style is very bad and not suited for mainstream wrestling, guys like Walter/Gunther are able to do it because they just have that little something extra about them, whereas Miro just falls very flat."

[4.0] "Original Comment from April 02 2022: Cosplay Magnum TA. Mainstay enhancement talent during Crockett's not so smooth transition into WCW. Mostly looked good while doing nothing, but was capable of working a competitive match and did now & again See also: Trent Knight. EDIT: He's better than the score I gave him but the write up explains it all. 4.25"

[4.0] "Original Comment from April 02 2022: Magnum TA cosplay enhancement talent from the late 80's that didn't stick around long after JCP transitioned into WCW. Mostly did nothing while looking good, was athletically inclined enough to throw great dropkicks and take some notable bumps. Career highlight: taking a fireball from "Hot Stuff" Eddie Gilbert at Clash of the Champions 7 "Guts and Glory". See also: Joe Cruz. EDIT: He's better than the score I gave him but the write up explains it all. 4.25"

[4.0] "Time to squash the tackling dummy! Pudgy do-nothing hapless wimp in the golden era of the WWF. I remember him mostly for the way he put over Greg Valentine but he did work with loads of heels and even some babyfaces. Had NOTHING, aside from some form of an unforgettable look for the era. Makes me think of Saturday Morning Cartoons and a bowl of milk, sugar & something that used to be a grain. 3.5"

[4.0] "Xia Li, in my opinion, was a missed opportunity for WWE. They still have time to make her into a credible challenger for anyone, but we all know they won't. She's decent in the ring from the few matches I've seen and I think her hard-hitting moves are something that the company has been lacking. Her little moment with Becky and the NXT Women's title had me interested, but then Becky lost the title and Xia was gone again. I think the only interesting thing that's happened for Xia so far was the Tian Sha group in NXT, but that didn't last long either. She's just kind of there at the moment, used for an occasional Main Event match or Battle Royal, I wish they would do something with her instead of just having her be another unimportant member of the roster."

[4.0] "Logan does what a celebrity wrestler does, he shows up and does a move that makes people think he's good. Then he's gone for months. People heavily overhype him when in reality, he's dangerous for superstars to compete against, nearly injuring Rey Mysterio. He says he is full-time into wrestling but then has 2 matches in the first 4 months of 2024... That's not full-time buddy. Go back to your waste of time youtube show."

[4.0] "She's a decent manager and at times good on the mic, that's about it. I've enjoyed Maxxine and her work so far, but I feel like her in-ring skills lower her rating. When she had her first match I was just as excited as the next person, but since then I feel like her matches have been too short or just bad. She'll get better with time, most people do, and when she does I'll have no problem making her rating higher. For now I think she should work more live events to polish up some issues in the ring and maybe work some Main Event matches to get used to being in front of the larger crowds."

[4.0] "Dude is a Create a Wrestler. For real. I cannot stand how this guy just sorta dances, and then wins for no reason despite looking almost as boring as Johnny Gargano, I will never understand why he is being pushed, and thats pretty much it. I got nothing else to say."

[4.0] "Nia Jax from 2017-2021 was one of the worst things I've ever seen in a ring, she simply didn't have a fight without a dangerous botch who could hurt someone, she didn't have a good fight, however, I have to recognize, Nia Jax in this return is ok, obviously he's not at the level of Becky Lynch, Charlotte, Asuka, Bianca Belair, Bayley, IYO SKY or Rhea Ripley, but she's much better, the Nia Jax of 2023-2024 is a Shawn Michaels compared to the Nia Jax of 2017-2021, maybe her being fired was good for her."

[4.0] "Never really liked him, since wwe i always thought he wasn't good and in aew i hate that purple hat himmick, but he had some good moments as a part of the J.A.S. Jack Hager is just not the type of wrestler that i likebut shout out to him for being arround all this years."

[4.0] "He was alright. Right guy at the wrong time imo, would've been great in the 80s but mid 2010s the gimmick just didn't work. His most noticeable work was being the stunt double of Miz, which just goes to show really what the crowd was like during those times... preferred comedy characters over somebody super serious like Sandow. I find it crazy how they put the MITB on him... was never going to be at that level, was always destined to be an IC or US champ. In-ring he was very average... which I think didn't help him either, to be honest. Boring gimmick and boring in-ring, not exactly a recipe for success."

[4.0] "In terms of a wrestling character he was very good, but the moment he stepped into a ring it just went downhill. The guy was just simply a bore to watch, his finishing move was neat but everything else just fell so flat. WWE really tried to make him into their next Latino star, but he was just a pure 100% heel who could never have worked as a babyface. I did really enjoy the setup they had with Ricardo Rodriguez introducing him and Del Rio coming out in some fancy ass car, really did make him feel different to everybody else on the roster. But again, the moment the bell rang it was just downhill, the guy couldn't put on an entertaining match even if he tried."

[4.0] "So damn boring. I think in-ring he was actually alright, probably helped having an amateur wrestling background. But man this guy had ZERO charisma! Like he had absolutely nothing aside from a good theme and being decent in-ring. Couldn't even talk on the mic... not going to take into account his lisp because I think people can easily be good on the mic regardless of a lisp. WWE tried so hard to make him into something, but he just couldn't fill that role. Hard to believe this guy won the MITB and became WHC. Can't exactly blame WWE for trying because on paper (aside from the mic work) he was actually alright but he never really had the ability to be a huge star."

[4.0] "Seems to get genuine heel heat but for the life of me I can't see why. Absolutely basic in-ring work despite having a father who's an all time great, and repetitive, unimaginative promo work. If his dad wasn't Rey Mysterio he wouldn't be anywhere near the roster."

[4.0] "I dont get this guy, hes only praised for his promo skills and thats not something to be good, nobody talks about his wresting work which is what professional wrestling is, just cus you can talk on the mic doesnt mean hes a great wrestler or "the mega star", i really dont see what yall think about this. He is average at best in the ring and all people talk about is his promos. well its WWE so it make sense but any other promotion he would not do so good. srry la knight fans but thats the truth."

[4.0] "Havent seen much of Adrianna Rizzo yet, but she seems like an okay manager for the Dangelo Family. Once there is more work going on with her maybe the rating will go up."

[4.0] "I think anything less than a 4 is a little harsh because she's not awful in-ring. She clearly likes professional wrestling and is pretty good at it, but she just lacks charisma. She's awful on the mic, the worst thing they could ever do is let her talk, her voice doesn't match her appearance nor does it match her persona as an MMA fighter. I know it's pretty wild to say that her voice doesn't match, but it is a genuine criticism and is something WWE should've worked around. She has a ceiling, you could put her in there with a main event talent and she would do well, but other than that she's just quite bland."

[4.0] "I just don't see much on Kemp. Much better then his brother, but that's not much. He'll be a decent hand, but he doesn't have much more to offer."

[4.0] "Mirai is awful, being a decent wrestler (debatable) is not a character. It didn't work in TJPW, didn't work in Stardom regardless of everything she was handed. Whatever she does next, I hope it's not in a character-driven promotion because she just doesn't have any personality and charisma. She won't draw a single seat for a big promotion. Everything she won in Stardom was a spit in the face of the other much talented Stardom wrestlers."

[4.0] "What's the hype for LA Knight? It seems that he is just some sort of a regular wrestler who happens to cosplay The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin. If this was the Attitude Era, maybe Knight would thrive with this gimmick. Nowadays when wrestling has become more aware of the quality and more focused on skill, this would be a failure. No question, he got the attention of the crowd at the palm of his hands. He's got some charisma to attract the masses but doesn't have the exuding aura on making him stand out like the rest of the roster. These annoying catchphrases, like "Yeah" is similar to the annoying "What" chants by Austin. His interviews had no substance, more like Rock-lite promos. Just relying on kiddie insults and it is not entertaining at all. In-ring, he is just a run-of-the-mill wrestler, not as good as AJ Styles or Gunther in that particular. He is not even good as John Cena either. Tell me one match that Knight had a memorable match so far, none. He couldn't even thrive in smaller promotions like TNA as Eli Drake, what more in WWE where they already have big stars like Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns. For me, he is just a personification of nostalgia. But if it were for me, I would just watch the Attitude Era Raw and Smackdown shows to listen to The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin and not listen to some copycat like LA Knight. Sorry, but LA Knight is just a lame character. I'd bet in like 2 years after he retires, most of the fans wouldn't remember LA Knight's "impact and influence" and they would still remember Rock, Austin, Cena and Punk. But points for crowd impact though."

[4.0] "She did good in her break out tournament match but that was about it. Her matches after that show that she's green and her new finishers are horrible. She should return to using the flatliner slam. Im happy that she was put in a group where she can improve (and obviously in time outshine her group bc my god are they a bunch of jobbers...) Plus she seem to already have a promising feud they can milk off in the long term with that Italian girl with the horrendous accent. UP: Here after her last match... I mean cmone hip strike as a finisher, girl i dont wanna give you a 3... Do a ddt or something, the kelly kelly bulldog ddt k2... Like get a grip"

[4.0] "Whether you love him or hate him, there's just something special about Darby. I know it's a bit of a meme to call him the Jeff Hardy of this generation, but in my opinion that's what he really is. My biggest issue with Darby and the reason as to why I've rated him so low is because of his overabundance of death-defying moves. He has gone on record to say he knows how to do them safely, which is great and all... but I think he's doing some real mental gymnastics if he thinks this won't eventually lead to a horrific injury. At the rate he's going, I would be very, very surprised if he's able to walk when he's in his mid 40s. I understand the kind of wrestler he is, and it's honestly refreshing to see somebody like him, but there's absolutely a time and place to do things. Just because you're able to do something, doesn't mean you should, especially on a weekly basis. His run with Sting was great, it'll probably go down, aside from the crazy stuff he puts his body through, as the career defining moment in his career. But, man... eventually something will happen and it's not going to be good. Lastly, the guy is pretty bad on the mic so best if he rarely gets the opportunity to talk. But yeah, low raiting because he doesn't know how and when to reel himself in, thinking he'll be ok in the future when he clearly won't be, can't give somebody too high of a raiting when they're willingly doing crazy stuff on a weekly basis like that."

[4.0] "Decent guy, a bad booker overall. The worst part of it all is that he seems immune to taking any advice from veterans who simply know better. He is, however, a good matchmaker, I'll give him that. Hence the rating is a 4 and not a 2. It would be impossible to rate him any higher than a 4 due to his inability to tell long-term, meaningful stories."

[4.0] "A vastly over rated manager. His gimmick is that of a savvy businessman when he ironically has only been able to sell one product, Brock Lesnar. A solid promo but his work as a manager actively hindered some of the talents he worked with and his run as the "Wise Man" with Roman has been fine but I challenge anyone to find a moment that was truly elevated by his involvement. An inspired booker, but I can't give a man kudos for being strapped to the rocket that is Roman Reigns and was Brock Lesnar."

[4.0] "Funnily enough, just happened to see this guy in action while looking for matches to rate/roast Luigi Primo on, and they had a short feud together. He's actually pretty decent! Solid if unremarkable heel worker with kind of a fun gimmick in the whole wine connoisseur thing, which maybe isn't super deep but is a nice twist on the "smarter than you" arrogant heel shtick. Or maybe I just find wine people insufferable to begin with. I appreciate the "grape stomping" spot in the corner to mesh with his gimmick."

[4.0] "All I remember from this guy was being associated with Baron Corbin, majority of his offense was shoulder tackles and having one of the goofiest entrances ever. Very uninteresting performer who offered nothing in WWE and is mostly forgettable."

[4.0] "He is really good at being an Uso, or yet another Bloodline goon. However, on his own he is a waste of television time. One of the issues being a tag member with your family causes is that it is difficult for you to stand out and currently Jimmy refuses to stand out. Maybe he can and will but that will require him taking some time away from it all to forge his own identity."

[4.0] "Jade looks like a star, however her fighting ability is not the best, which is a shame, since because of that you cannot take full advantage of her ability. Has she improved? Yes, but I hope she improves more."

[4.0] "I never found anything that Shannon Moore did to interest me. I even watched his TNA run and he was just weird and nothing more. ECW gimmick was the worst. In 2003, Paul Heyman tried to give him a chance to become a star on Smackdown after Matt Hardy jumped to Raw (before that, he was the punchball of the team). It did not work, because Moore did not show any charisma. Not really bad in the ring, but he is one of the cruiserweights that never got me hyped for anything. He missed his chances!"

[4.0] "Bullet Ant clearly had a good run in Chakra but Prince Magod Ali didnt get a chance. Shame he had to go for another career before worth out or broke. Ursa faired unethically in mantras."

[4.0] "Hoot's Promo are the shits but he and Ricky Morton are a tremendous tag team, he was never going to be a singles guy with his lack of a promo but his in-ring was solid. Let's put it this way you were never going to buy a ticket to go see him in singles competition."

[4.0] "[4.0] "Toni is not a bad fighter, I loved her time in STARDOM where she showed a lot of potential. I loved her match with Io Shira, one of my favorite matches. However, since she debuted this new gimmick (Timeless), She hasn't had a good fight and seems to have gotten worse on a technical level. She looks slow in the ring, which is a disappointment. She must go back to being the Toni we saw in Japan. Her matches are boring and difficult to watch. She is the AEW women's champion, she has not had a good match."

[4.0] "I met Deonna for the first time when she was in NXT and she was still very young, she seemed like a good prospect to me, but they didn't give her many opportunities and they fired her, however, she managed to reinvent herself in TNA, achieving a good run there. That's why I expected a lot from her in AEW, however so far her run in AEW has been very bad. She seems slow and she hasn't put up a good fight so far. I keep waiting for more from her."