Latest Comments

[4.0] "Xia Li, in my opinion, was a missed opportunity for WWE. They still have time to make her into a credible challenger for anyone, but we all know they won't. She's decent in the ring from the few matches I've seen and I think her hard-hitting moves are something that the company has been lacking. Her little moment with Becky and the NXT Women's title had me interested, but then Becky lost the title and Xia was gone again. I think the only interesting thing that's happened for Xia so far was the Tian Sha group in NXT, but that didn't last long either. She's just kind of there at the moment, used for an occasional Main Event match or Battle Royal, I wish they would do something with her instead of just having her be another unimportant member of the roster."

[4.0] "Logan does what a celebrity wrestler does, he shows up and does a move that makes people think he's good. Then he's gone for months. People heavily overhype him when in reality, he's dangerous for superstars to compete against, nearly injuring Rey Mysterio. He says he is full-time into wrestling but then has 2 matches in the first 4 months of 2024... That's not full-time buddy. Go back to your waste of time youtube show."

[4.0] "She's a decent manager and at times good on the mic, that's about it. I've enjoyed Maxxine and her work so far, but I feel like her in-ring skills lower her rating. When she had her first match I was just as excited as the next person, but since then I feel like her matches have been too short or just bad. She'll get better with time, most people do, and when she does I'll have no problem making her rating higher. For now I think she should work more live events to polish up some issues in the ring and maybe work some Main Event matches to get used to being in front of the larger crowds."

[4.0] "Dude is a Create a Wrestler. For real. I cannot stand how this guy just sorta dances, and then wins for no reason despite looking almost as boring as Johnny Gargano, I will never understand why he is being pushed, and thats pretty much it. I got nothing else to say."

[4.0] "Nia Jax from 2017-2021 was one of the worst things I've ever seen in a ring, she simply didn't have a fight without a dangerous botch who could hurt someone, she didn't have a good fight, however, I have to recognize, Nia Jax in this return is ok, obviously he's not at the level of Becky Lynch, Charlotte, Asuka, Bianca Belair, Bayley, IYO SKY or Rhea Ripley, but she's much better, the Nia Jax of 2023-2024 is a Shawn Michaels compared to the Nia Jax of 2017-2021, maybe her being fired was good for her."

[4.0] "Never really liked him, since wwe i always thought he wasn't good and in aew i hate that purple hat himmick, but he had some good moments as a part of the J.A.S. Jack Hager is just not the type of wrestler that i likebut shout out to him for being arround all this years."

[4.0] "He was alright. Right guy at the wrong time imo, would've been great in the 80s but mid 2010s the gimmick just didn't work. His most noticeable work was being the stunt double of Miz, which just goes to show really what the crowd was like during those times... preferred comedy characters over somebody super serious like Sandow. I find it crazy how they put the MITB on him... was never going to be at that level, was always destined to be an IC or US champ. In-ring he was very average... which I think didn't help him either, to be honest. Boring gimmick and boring in-ring, not exactly a recipe for success."

[4.0] "In terms of a wrestling character he was very good, but the moment he stepped into a ring it just went downhill. The guy was just simply a bore to watch, his finishing move was neat but everything else just fell so flat. WWE really tried to make him into their next Latino star, but he was just a pure 100% heel who could never have worked as a babyface. I did really enjoy the setup they had with Ricardo Rodriguez introducing him and Del Rio coming out in some fancy ass car, really did make him feel different to everybody else on the roster. But again, the moment the bell rang it was just downhill, the guy couldn't put on an entertaining match even if he tried."

[4.0] "So damn boring. I think in-ring he was actually alright, probably helped having an amateur wrestling background. But man this guy had ZERO charisma! Like he had absolutely nothing aside from a good theme and being decent in-ring. Couldn't even talk on the mic... not going to take into account his lisp because I think people can easily be good on the mic regardless of a lisp. WWE tried so hard to make him into something, but he just couldn't fill that role. Hard to believe this guy won the MITB and became WHC. Can't exactly blame WWE for trying because on paper (aside from the mic work) he was actually alright but he never really had the ability to be a huge star."

[4.0] "Seems to get genuine heel heat but for the life of me I can't see why. Absolutely basic in-ring work despite having a father who's an all time great, and repetitive, unimaginative promo work. If his dad wasn't Rey Mysterio he wouldn't be anywhere near the roster."

[4.0] "I dont get this guy, hes only praised for his promo skills and thats not something to be good, nobody talks about his wresting work which is what professional wrestling is, just cus you can talk on the mic doesnt mean hes a great wrestler or "the mega star", i really dont see what yall think about this. He is average at best in the ring and all people talk about is his promos. well its WWE so it make sense but any other promotion he would not do so good. srry la knight fans but thats the truth."

[4.0] "Havent seen much of Adrianna Rizzo yet, but she seems like an okay manager for the Dangelo Family. Once there is more work going on with her maybe the rating will go up."

[4.0] "I think anything less than a 4 is a little harsh because she's not awful in-ring. She clearly likes professional wrestling and is pretty good at it, but she just lacks charisma. She's awful on the mic, the worst thing they could ever do is let her talk, her voice doesn't match her appearance nor does it match her persona as an MMA fighter. I know it's pretty wild to say that her voice doesn't match, but it is a genuine criticism and is something WWE should've worked around. She has a ceiling, you could put her in there with a main event talent and she would do well, but other than that she's just quite bland."

[4.0] "I just don't see much on Kemp. Much better then his brother, but that's not much. He'll be a decent hand, but he doesn't have much more to offer."

[4.0] "Mirai is awful, being a decent wrestler (debatable) is not a character. It didn't work in TJPW, didn't work in Stardom regardless of everything she was handed. Whatever she does next, I hope it's not in a character-driven promotion because she just doesn't have any personality and charisma. She won't draw a single seat for a big promotion. Everything she won in Stardom was a spit in the face of the other much talented Stardom wrestlers."

[4.0] "What's the hype for LA Knight? It seems that he is just some sort of a regular wrestler who happens to cosplay The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin. If this was the Attitude Era, maybe Knight would thrive with this gimmick. Nowadays when wrestling has become more aware of the quality and more focused on skill, this would be a failure. No question, he got the attention of the crowd at the palm of his hands. He's got some charisma to attract the masses but doesn't have the exuding aura on making him stand out like the rest of the roster. These annoying catchphrases, like "Yeah" is similar to the annoying "What" chants by Austin. His interviews had no substance, more like Rock-lite promos. Just relying on kiddie insults and it is not entertaining at all. In-ring, he is just a run-of-the-mill wrestler, not as good as AJ Styles or Gunther in that particular. He is not even good as John Cena either. Tell me one match that Knight had a memorable match so far, none. He couldn't even thrive in smaller promotions like TNA as Eli Drake, what more in WWE where they already have big stars like Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns. For me, he is just a personification of nostalgia. But if it were for me, I would just watch the Attitude Era Raw and Smackdown shows to listen to The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin and not listen to some copycat like LA Knight. Sorry, but LA Knight is just a lame character. I'd bet in like 2 years after he retires, most of the fans wouldn't remember LA Knight's "impact and influence" and they would still remember Rock, Austin, Cena and Punk. But points for crowd impact though."

[4.0] "She did good in her break out tournament match but that was about it. Her matches after that show that she's green and her new finishers are horrible. She should return to using the flatliner slam. Im happy that she was put in a group where she can improve (and obviously in time outshine her group bc my god are they a bunch of jobbers...) Plus she seem to already have a promising feud they can milk off in the long term with that Italian girl with the horrendous accent. UP: Here after her last match... I mean cmone hip strike as a finisher, girl i dont wanna give you a 3... Do a ddt or something, the kelly kelly bulldog ddt k2... Like get a grip"

[4.0] "Whether you love him or hate him, there's just something special about Darby. I know it's a bit of a meme to call him the Jeff Hardy of this generation, but in my opinion that's what he really is. My biggest issue with Darby and the reason as to why I've rated him so low is because of his overabundance of death-defying moves. He has gone on record to say he knows how to do them safely, which is great and all... but I think he's doing some real mental gymnastics if he thinks this won't eventually lead to a horrific injury. At the rate he's going, I would be very, very surprised if he's able to walk when he's in his mid 40s. I understand the kind of wrestler he is, and it's honestly refreshing to see somebody like him, but there's absolutely a time and place to do things. Just because you're able to do something, doesn't mean you should, especially on a weekly basis. His run with Sting was great, it'll probably go down, aside from the crazy stuff he puts his body through, as the career defining moment in his career. But, man... eventually something will happen and it's not going to be good. Lastly, the guy is pretty bad on the mic so best if he rarely gets the opportunity to talk. But yeah, low raiting because he doesn't know how and when to reel himself in, thinking he'll be ok in the future when he clearly won't be, can't give somebody too high of a raiting when they're willingly doing crazy stuff on a weekly basis like that."

[4.0] "Decent guy, a bad booker overall. The worst part of it all is that he seems immune to taking any advice from veterans who simply know better. He is, however, a good matchmaker, I'll give him that. Hence the rating is a 4 and not a 2. It would be impossible to rate him any higher than a 4 due to his inability to tell long-term, meaningful stories."

[4.0] "A vastly over rated manager. His gimmick is that of a savvy businessman when he ironically has only been able to sell one product, Brock Lesnar. A solid promo but his work as a manager actively hindered some of the talents he worked with and his run as the "Wise Man" with Roman has been fine but I challenge anyone to find a moment that was truly elevated by his involvement. An inspired booker, but I can't give a man kudos for being strapped to the rocket that is Roman Reigns and was Brock Lesnar."

[4.0] "Funnily enough, just happened to see this guy in action while looking for matches to rate/roast Luigi Primo on, and they had a short feud together. He's actually pretty decent! Solid if unremarkable heel worker with kind of a fun gimmick in the whole wine connoisseur thing, which maybe isn't super deep but is a nice twist on the "smarter than you" arrogant heel shtick. Or maybe I just find wine people insufferable to begin with. I appreciate the "grape stomping" spot in the corner to mesh with his gimmick."

[4.0] "All I remember from this guy was being associated with Baron Corbin, majority of his offense was shoulder tackles and having one of the goofiest entrances ever. Very uninteresting performer who offered nothing in WWE and is mostly forgettable."

[4.0] "He is really good at being an Uso, or yet another Bloodline goon. However, on his own he is a waste of television time. One of the issues being a tag member with your family causes is that it is difficult for you to stand out and currently Jimmy refuses to stand out. Maybe he can and will but that will require him taking some time away from it all to forge his own identity."

[4.0] "Jade looks like a star, however her fighting ability is not the best, which is a shame, since because of that you cannot take full advantage of her ability. Has she improved? Yes, but I hope she improves more."

[4.0] "I never found anything that Shannon Moore did to interest me. I even watched his TNA run and he was just weird and nothing more. ECW gimmick was the worst. In 2003, Paul Heyman tried to give him a chance to become a star on Smackdown after Matt Hardy jumped to Raw (before that, he was the punchball of the team). It did not work, because Moore did not show any charisma. Not really bad in the ring, but he is one of the cruiserweights that never got me hyped for anything. He missed his chances!"

[4.0] "Bullet Ant clearly had a good run in Chakra but Prince Magod Ali didnt get a chance. Shame he had to go for another career before worth out or broke. Ursa faired unethically in mantras."

[4.0] "Hoot's Promo are the shits but he and Ricky Morton are a tremendous tag team, he was never going to be a singles guy with his lack of a promo but his in-ring was solid. Let's put it this way you were never going to buy a ticket to go see him in singles competition."

[4.0] "[4.0] "Toni is not a bad fighter, I loved her time in STARDOM where she showed a lot of potential. I loved her match with Io Shira, one of my favorite matches. However, since she debuted this new gimmick (Timeless), She hasn't had a good fight and seems to have gotten worse on a technical level. She looks slow in the ring, which is a disappointment. She must go back to being the Toni we saw in Japan. Her matches are boring and difficult to watch. She is the AEW women's champion, she has not had a good match."

[4.0] "I met Deonna for the first time when she was in NXT and she was still very young, she seemed like a good prospect to me, but they didn't give her many opportunities and they fired her, however, she managed to reinvent herself in TNA, achieving a good run there. That's why I expected a lot from her in AEW, however so far her run in AEW has been very bad. She seems slow and she hasn't put up a good fight so far. I keep waiting for more from her."

[4.0] "Aya has gotten stronger after her return. Her recent rivalry with Sayaka sets her up perfectly for a heel turn. While their 1:1 match ended up in a time limit draw, it was clear that Aya come out on top. If the match had continued on, Aya would have won. I would love to see more matches between the two and a heel turn from Aya will be amazing. I expect Aya to become Sayaka's nemesis and torment her for months after it."

[4.0] "I don't mean this 4 as "she's not good at what she does, " but more what the parenthetical says...adequate. I find her entrance and gear to be fantastic, but there isn't much more to her than that. The entirety of the House of Black is giving more "Undertaker Lite" than something much more defined. She's very young, so there's plenty of time for her to become better on both the mic and in the ring. As it stands, I'm left wanting."

[4.0] "Mantasia had an eye catching gimmick to woo the kids and younger MCU demographic. But just didnt go far and wasnt intended to go farther. Battles with fellow peers of the slam Mike Starrs wrestling school such as Artemis Spencer, Matt XStatic and Daniel Adonis completing in All Star and ECCW were the small exposure that should got him booked more. Probably another life we all could contemplated for arm bands with his logo on them."

[4.0] "He can be entertaining, but I have never been a fan of his small pushes. I do not think he ever should have won the IC title, he damaged the title IMO. The fact that he won the Women's battle royal, although a product of the time and not his fault, was also terrible and should have never happened."

[4.0] "Only saw him outside of the ref role recently when he teamed with Akiyama and went for the tag titles. I'd say "adequate" is about right."

[4.0] "[UPDATING] Well, she is like kind of starting to show up more personality with her current Candice LeRae heel storyline. Her selling and movement is kind of improving too, but she is still average and a bit slow. She also has a good look and presence. Hopefully her heel turn helps her, by now, she is a four."

[4.0] "She is an adequate performer, nothing very interesting. She is goot at wrestling but lacks a self-personality, specially with her current heel persona, I just can't take her seriously. She is trying too much to look "evil" but she don't has it. She is also copycatting AJ Lee a lot, most of her promos and mannerisms are based off on her and its annoying. It almost makes you want to shout at her: "find yourself a personality."

[5.0] "One of the few wrestlers who make it worth going to British shows post-Pandemic. Emotive like nobody else, a sublime seller and one of the most empathetic faces I've ever seen. Revision April 2024: Isn't working quite as well as he was - he's being booked as more dominant and it really doesn't suit him."

[5.0] "Tackling dummy for Crockett & then Jim Herd's WCW. The thing you will recall most is his fiery red mullet. He did fine with bumping and selling but was completely void of offense. It's all about the legendary red mullet, that's the takeaway. 4.75"

[5.0] "He hung in their in the attitude era, had some good matches and a decent gimmick, a mid carder in that era is not bad , the stuff he did with his cousin crash was entertaining, his gimmicks before sucked, after the attitude era he didnt really do much, him saying he would hang with fighters in the ufc is fuckin delusional the guy thinks he tougher than he actually is"

[5.0] "I do not understand why Don Callis is given so much telvision time. I don't find him to be a particularly good talker, I think that he is actually rather nowhere near the level that would justify the time he gets. He definitely gets fairly good reactions but I think it is somewhat unfair that he gets so many talented wrestlers in his stable when other managers could promote them much better."

[5.0] "The potential is there. She reminds me of Kelly Kelly. A bit bland but, remember it's only LV up. We have to wait for her NXT debut. She already has the basics down. Hopefully they keep her as a face."

[5.0] "AEW loves three kinds of wrestling, Flippy Floppy, Outlaw Mudshow Bullshit, and faker than Sable's tits. Rey Fenix is in the first category, and he is not very good. His piledriver to Jon Moxley wasn't a freak accident, it was damn dangerous and stupid, and if I had to guess Moxley said something to the effect of (read this in a heavy smoker's voice) "You know what would be some cool shit? drop me on my head. give me a concussion. That's badass. do that." Jeez. Anyway, Fenix is dangerous and needs to go back to class before he's in a ring again."

[5.0] "When the territory days where truly dying (all but toe tagged) this guy came along and was rather good enhancement talent. Babyface muscle hulk. Did great in the UWF and was even given a bit of a limelight while the company lasted. Moved on to be in the same role for a nearly deceased World Class. That is where I found his magnum opus: World Class Championship Wrestling June 25 1988 In this match with Rick Hazard (who was usually a referee but DID have a few matches) as his partner, they took on Samu and Fatu (Rikishi) The Samoan Swat Team! My gawd he took a legendary ass kicking here. He does a backflip oversell for a Double Headbutt, completely throws himself halfway to Montana on multiple bumps and took some SICK kicks to face/neck. The SST were new arrivals to the almost officially dead territory and needed to be put over strong, this guy does "the job" and then some! Gotta respect that type of work ethic from a nobody."

[5.0] "I wish I could give him a higher rating. I know he's good. I've seen his Roppongi 3K stuff. He's a natural babyface. Unfortunately he is dreadful as a heel, borderline unwatchably so. Taking a guy whose main selling point is he's a heroic power wrestling junior heavyweight and turning him into a cookie cutter cowardly sneak is braindead booking."

[5.0] "There are two pluses I have to give Van Hammer. One was as a child with only a limited tape collection to watch wrestling on, I was fascinated by the fall count anywhere match with Cactus Jack. Second, the names. Heavy Metal Van Hammer just sounded cool and I cannot explain how hilarious I find the fact that he thought he was too good to be a Private in the Misfits in Action so he became General Stash and completely negated the pot joke."

[5.0] "I mean, he's an ok wrestler who is obviously best suited in the comedy role. Nothing really special about him aside from the fact he can make you laugh, really enjoyed his work with Devitt as Apollo 55 though. Feel like that was probably the best of Taguchi, hasn't really done anything noteworthy since, which is a shame because that team ended well over a decade ago now."

[5.0] "As of right now I have to give him a 5. If Vince had stayed, this guy would've been a world champion by now. All his momentum went when Vince left and HHH took over, kind of feels like HHH doesn't know what to do with the guy. Has a fantastic look, good on the mic, in-ring is good, no doubt he'll be a champion in the future but as of right now he really needs to get back on track in regards to fulfilling his potential. I will say this though, he's never going to be on the level of a John Cena. Will never be the "guy" in WWE, I can honestly see him as the next Miz, which isn't a knock at all because Miz is a decent wrestler who is a several time World Champion, but he'll never hit the level of a top main event guy for long periods of time. Would love to be proven wrong though."

[5.0] "An incredibly boring wrestler who nobody liked as Champion. A pretty good booker, although the NXT Black and Gold roster would be hard to screw up. Had his character be presented as a smart guy as an excuse for him to be one of the slowest wrestlers under 40 you'll ever see."

[5.0] "When I was a kid, I thought Batista is the coolest man on the planet. Boy, how naive we are. Upon growing up, I realized that Batista is all pure muscle but no substance. I don't recall any Batista match that is great. Most of his matches are relying on his power and most of it are mediocre. He has the size and power but that's all he is. In a world of Vader, Bam Bam Bigelow and Keith Lee, which are athletically impressive big men, Batista turns out to be unimpressive in comparison to them. I only loved his Evolution days whereas Batista is no-talk all-action imposing specimen in the WWE. Some few good points are his feuds with Triple H and Undertaker, and a valuable asset to the company because of his looks and popularity. Also at certain times, he looks like a World Champion material. He dresses as a champion, looks as a champion and acts as a champion. Sadly, if he cannot be athletically impressive, at least he could be more variant on his arsenal of moves. Maybe is the stereotype WWE practiced upon big men like Batista. Regardless, he is one of the last big megastars in WWE along with John Cena."

[5.0] "This guy just doesn't stand out to me. He was good in tag teams, but I just have never found him interesting. He's got an okay look but that's about all. Middle of the road talent."

[5.0] "I hate the way he books and I'll get to that in a minute, but I can't say that he's all bad because yeah, this guy gave the industry a new breath when it was dying, but now it's too much. We NEEDED AEW in the first years of its existence, the promotion helped a lot of released superstars from the WWE (Moxley, Swerve, Danielson, Claudio, Storm, Athena...) and a lot of indie stars (Eddie, The ELITE, MJF, Lucha Bros, Orange...) to make a name for themselves in a bigger stageand that a VERY good thing ! BUT He clearly is a fan playing TEW in real life, he doesn't know how to manage a lockeroom and it has shown multiple times, Guevara fighted TWICE ? Nothing bad happened, Punk and Elite fight ? Nothing to help them getting along, just hoping and praying. Jungle Boy vs Punk ? Yeah fire Punk and do not talk to Perry... Logical to do this when you're an adult... He isn't a good leader in this company and clearly, Danielson and Christopher who are among those whose choices are important inside the lockerooms, do a better job than him. his booking is crap too, he doesn't know how to do short termed stories OR when to stop for storyline, him not knowing where to stop ruined multiple storylines (The Devil story is my biggest disappointment in YEARS in wrestling) and also yeah He's bad with women, Toni Storm has the best gimmick in all of AEW right now and she's featured on tv about 5mn a week ? that's so so so bad, he clearly needs a lot of writers to help him cause if he continues, in a few years he'll be as bad as VKM was when it came to storylines... I hope he gets a breath of fresh air, he needs it"

[5.0] "In-ring she's good, other than that she doesn't have much going for her. She has no character, zero charisma and her promos are bad. Her best work was with Trish Stratus who carried Zoey on her back, her team with Shayna does not help at all in the character or charisma departments. Also her title run with Io in NXT was just pointless and an attempt to get her over by putting her with a big name star and it didn't work."

[5.0] "A great wrestler who never reached his full potential because of how far his head is stuck up his ass. Low Ki was at one point one of the best in the world, but between shooting on opponents, backing out of matches when he's booked to lose, and generally being a whiny bitch, he's held himself back. I couldn't stand that stupid Agent 47 cosplay he constantly wore in the mid-2010s. Great matches, meh promo, shit person."

[5.0] "[5.2] The CM Punk of the early-to-mid 2010s was practically a god. He was a man on top of his game in the biggest promotion in the world, reigniting interest in it during one of its worst times and a permanent highlight of a show that tended to verge on unwatchable. Sure, he was never quite as good in-ring as his fellow early ROH alums, but he made up for it by being one of the best talkers in the wrestling world, arguably a top 10 of all time, and was in a place where he could rest on that. The CM Punk of 2024 is none of that. He has retained his world-class skills on the microphone but realized the business had moved on from him and was bitter over it. His second AEW run and subsequent return to WWE just made it apparent that Phil Brooks has become a toxic, self-important parody of everything that made him great. All of this might have been forgiven if he was still decent in the ring, but he isn't. The in-ring work was always a weak point for Punk, but he has slowed down and can't stay healthy for the life of him. Of the two years since Double or Nothing 2022, almost half of that time has been spent on the shelf. What good he has in his legacy is simply not enough to override his current-day mediocrity, or how hard he has seemingly intentionally worked to destroy any goodwill he had with all but the most casual of fans, who have nothing to frame his impact but the hushed reverent tones of those remembering a man who is now a shadow of himself."

[5.0] "Jinder Mahal is that wrestler that you like because of something bad that WWE did, he's not good in the ring, he has the throne as the worst WWE World Champion in history, but after this reign, he's kind of cool? I blame V**** Mc***** for making me like Jinder Mahal, today he is overhated and underrated, he improved a lot in the ring, in his mic skill and gained charisma, but in 2017 in that World Title reign he deserved the hate."

[5.0] "Not that good, but very Overhated, this rivalry against Bron Breakker was very good, Von Wagner is improving a lot in all aspects, I really hope he becomes a good wrestler."

[5.0] "He has a great look and does have some cool moves, namely the Powerbomb Symphony and Swanton, but he's just not good enough in the ring or on the mic to really fit well in AEW"

[5.0] "Kinda stiff at the little I have seen of her, second match and she did very little moves, but yet I think she has potential. We have to watch her in action more frequently to get a good overview on her wrestling abilities. Currently I am rating her like this since she hasn't prove something more interesting out of her great body and good looks."

[5.0] "A perfectly fine wrestler, obviously the more athletic but less charismatic of the Smash Bros. Sweet top rope moonsault moment during the Dark Order vs Elite Ghostbusters match, cute interactions with Anna Jay but that's about it as far as it goes for memorable AEW appearances.."

[5.0] "Pretty cooked whenever he leaves Chris Jericho's shadow. Pretty much any time I hear about him outside of kayfabe, it's negative. You literally can't turn him face, they've tried multiple times. He just has a face you want to punch, but even his heel work ends there. Can't cut a promo. High athleticism, but that's still middle-of-the-pack in AEW. Maybe he can turn things around, but I think he might need an excursion in Japan or hop to another promotion like TNA or MLW or something."

[5.0] "The "Anti Kota Ibushi" in that he could have been a huge star in anything he did: pro wrestling - Western, Japanese or shoot style or a multiple belt champ in MMA in multiple orgs but... Didn't. One of the true "what ifs" in wrestling and in legit shoot wrestling. Walked into NJPW with their main star Yuji Nagata and had a banger of a match, that was laid out perfect to get a loss but not take any aura hit from it - and then did... NOTHING after. Has size, a scary presence, legit skills both in fighting and in the ring and passable promo work. He could have had a long career as a bully MMA style shit-heel for an IC belt, and been an high midcard star in any major organization. Makes you wonder WHY no org wants to work with him for very long. Could have been anything he wanted, but now in his mid 40s, the sun has set."

[5.0] "She is not bad, but really needs a change. She is not a "latina", yeah she has Puerto Rican heritage, but she was born and raised in the U.S. dude she is from Miami, Florida... She tries to speak spanish but makes me cringe since she has no idea on how to do so, and then those dance and hip moves she does while doing her entrance lol, more than being sexy she makes me laugh, she really needs to stop doing that. Another basic chick just like Raquel Rodríguez, Elektra López, Rosa Mendes etc. that try to be "latinas" when they are not, it annoys. In-ring she is good but not great, and in mic she needs a lot of help. Hope WWE is not pushing her based on her looks cause yeah she has a great body and all, but it will be a complete flop once she is on the main roster, if she makes it, most likely she will be paired up with the "Latino World Order" or some Santos Escobar's stable... Very generic girl."

[5.0] "Adam Pearce is alright i guess. He can be funny but he is kinda boring. He has the general manager role and hes had it for a long time, so that works for him. He would be higher if he had any more enthusiasm, the only time i would like to see him on my screen if the icon Chelsea Green is there too."

[5.0] "I can't rate her too low because as mid as Maria was overall, she is above her fellow redhead Eva Marie in pretty much every category. She had a pretty solid run as Santino's girlfriend. Santino was also peaking at the time, stealing people's sandwiches and stuff. I actually vividly remember the little game shows they would have where Ron Simmons would end up winning Maria away at the end of the game. Corny Looney Tunes level stuff but I liked it. Everything else, eh."

[5.0] "One of the best promos in the history of the business. He's capable of putting on great matches with good logic and psychology and demonstrates a deep passion for pro wrestling. He's also a thin skinned and emotionally immature manchild. He reminds me a lot of Cam Newton. They're personal frontrunners. When things are going well it's all smiles and high fives. The second something happens it's frowning and tantrums. Even worse than all of that is his performative social views. You can't claim to be for women and then hire Jim Cornette's attorney. He's a man pushing 50 with the emotional intelligence and maturity of a teenager."

[5.0] "I don't see the hype behind Roxanne, I mean she's alright in the ring, but her promos aren't the best and her character work is eh... Her work as a heel just doesn't seem believable to me, it seems to fake & forced. In the ring she's alright, but that depends on her opponent; her match with Lyra at Stand & Deliver was just plain boring, but her match against Natalya on NXT was pretty good. She doesn't really have a character besides 'The Prodigy' and what kind of character is that really, she's got limited charisma and being a heel just doesn't suit her and being a face wasn't doing it either... Maybe I'll come back to change this in the future once she gets called up, maybe she'll develop there, but she should be better developed before moving up."

[5.0] "I cannot tell if NXT is underutilizing this performer or if the performer is not capable at the scale they wished him to be. He debuted on NXT with a very interesting character promo and never elaborated further meaning the character lacks the ground and base motivation to really get an audience behind him. Since then he has wrestled in okay midcard feuds with no real drive or meaning. I think he has shown flashes of something greater but until then, Lexis is resting in mediocrity."

[5.0] "lets be real, hes only considered "great" was cus of his reign, There is nothing special about roman. is in ring work is not bad but isnt good, same outcome usally happens with interference. all he says is agknoldge me and stuff, he barely had good matches with him being world champion. and hes only praised cus of is reign. sure it was good but finally its over and a new era has begun. all through i dont watch wwe cus its not my style. I still focus on the wrestlers and roman i believe needs to improve more. everyone always has to judge on character, but lets be real thats not professional wrestling. Maybe on wwe terms. but no way roman is an all time great. Sure, he is one of the biggest names in wrestling history, but the fact people call him the greatest of all time so funny to me, sure he can be entertaining. but thats just it. hs tribal chief gimmick is one of the best heel charaters of all time. but the dude is not a legend."

[5.0] "The CM Punk of old truly embodied the punk rock ethos, but just like many aging punk rockers he decided to take the golden pathed road of hypocrisy for the almighty dollar. There's really no shred of punk left in the man, just a shell of former performer whose body has fallen apart despite people 15 years his senior having successful runs. His modern value is purely based off of nostalgia, cult following and controversy which makes him less the modern Bret Hart and more the modern Hogan, someone shoved down our throats and is way past his prime, someone who claims to stand for one thing but represents the polar opposite. I think Punk's favorite band Minor Threat put it best; small man, big mouth."

[5.0] "Could be the female Goldberg. "COULD" being the operative word there. She has all the pros and all the cons of Goldberg, her only benefit is that she's (so far) been booked by good pens. If she continues to be booked correctly she will be huge, but we've seen how every one of these cheap Goldberg imitations has fizzled out. As it stands I don't know anyone could score her above a 7 when, by this sites standards, she only has one singles match with a score higher than 6/10."

[5.0] "July 3rd 2023, 0 rating: One of the worst women's wrestlers I've ever seen, she injured and botched everyone she was in the ring with and she sucked. Edit, April 11th 2024: So uh.. here we are lol upon watching her 2nd run she's I'm not even kidding turned into an actual GOOD WRESTLER! I can't give her higher cause her promo ability and her first run, but she's had quite A few good matches with good performances from her already and thats enough for me to boost her, to A 5."

[5.0] "Brett Semtex strikes me as having a lot of potential, so I hope and expect my original rating of a 5 to increase over the next few years. He has a bit of a mini Brock Lesnar thing going on, with a good luck and athleticism, using a blend of amateur wrestling and pseudo-MMA offense, and even employing the F5. He is still green, but there is a lot to like about him for someone with three years of experience."

[5.0] "An overrated wrestler, being famous due to perfect build in 2004 and his spectacular finisher. After some great rivalry in his first, he started showing his limits, with boring bouts, incredibly slow and dull performances, bad behaviours behind the curtain. He is a great heel and talker, with good psychology, but overrated."

[5.0] "Jey is a guy who is just pushed and pushed and pushed beyond his ability. He is a solid hand who can put on a solid WWE style match, but nothing he does really elevates the sport. The fact that his feud with his own brother was one of the worst matches to stink up a wrestlemania speaks wonders of his limits. He is a solid enhancer and if he stayed that way I would rate him higher."

[5.0] "I will give Jimmy Uso some slack, he is trying to find his footing as a solo competitor, but I feel like he isn't quite ready as a singles guy. As it stands, he's just a less charismatic version of Jey Uso. While he can wrestle and The Uso's are a great tag team, he has nothing going for him as a personality or talker, he's just a cardboard cutout. Also, that match he had with Jey Uso SUCKED!"

[5.0] "Despite my bias towards NJPW, this is one of the rare instances that I criticize a New Japan wrestler. EVIL might possibly be one of the worst guys in NJPW roster. He was a solid performer during his time at Los Ingobernables de Japon, had good to great matches there. He had an amazing chemistry with SANADA as a tag team that made them won multiple tag team titles. But ever since he went to Bullet Club and then House of Torture, he became a mediocre wrestler. His reign as the IWGP Heavyweight Champion in 2020 may considered be the worst title reign in NJPW history, simple because I think EVIL doesn't deserve it at the time. It felt rushed and he's obviously not ready to be a main eventer. What's worse is after he lost the title, he never recovered and fell into obscurity. His matches nowadays are mostly interferences from his stablemates and his cheating tactics have been repetitive. Sad to see the state of EVIL these days. A very promising talent that turned to be one of the most unbearable guys in the company. I hope there would be a chance to improve on EVIL. Focus more on working on a match and with less shenanigans, he could thrive and make a match better even as a villain. Just try it, NJPW."

[5.0] "Ahmed Johnson had a great presentation in the WWF where he had a unique look and fans loved him because of his raw intensity and his ridiculous promos even though you could never understand a word he was saying! Unfortunately his main drawback was that he was not good to watch in the ring. He ended up with a bad reputation for hurting his opponents, was injury prone and looked prone to gassing very early in matches. His most enjoyable feud was with Faarooq and the Nation of Domination which peaked with a chaotic street fight where he teamed with LOD at Wrestlemania 13. Easily the second best match on that show."

[5.0] "HAYATA is a weird wrestler, he's got a nice moveset with flashy and fluid moves, his look is pretty cool and looks like he's charismatic but in reality HAYATA is a really uninspired wrestler who transmits nothing when he wrestle, he's heel but not detestable at all, he wrestles like he goes through the motions and it makes him really uninteresting to watch but sometimes he can't have an entertaining match, it depends on his opponents of course but when he faces guys like Yo-Hey or Seiki Yoshioka, it is pretty but otherwise most of the time he's boring and i don't understand what NOAH are seeing in him."

[5.0] "An absolutely amazing wrestler who killed his own momentum and career with his own attitude issues and reckless endangerment. The list goes on and on about the amount of backstage politicing, refusing to lose, legitmately injuring other wrestlers without care and the burnt bridges in ROH, NJPW & other companies. Low Ki who was once one of the best wrestlers in the world is now known as someone who's hard to work with, hard to please & someone who had their head up their own ass."

[5.0] "Out of both Usos, Jimmy Uso seems to be the less valueable player of out of the two. He has the same exact moveset as Jey Uso but he has less of a character now with his recent heel turn. Probably one of the worst heel turns of the 2020s. Jimmy Uso has failed to get over with the crowd and he went from "Nobodys Bitch" to a lackey in the Bloodline. I hope he turns face soon because right now he was one of the most basic and boring dudes on the roster."

[5.0] "Man, what has happened with Jimmy over the past year? He has fallen off a ton since he broke away from his brother Jey and seems to have no charisma nor have anything going for him right now. Playing a lackey as a singles wrestler in the Bloodline is hurting Jimmy and it doesn't help that he has regressed in-ring somewhat. Jimmy obviously pales in comparison to Jey at this moment and the only thing that could perhaps save him from falling off completely is a reunion with his brother, which probably won't be happening for some time."

[5.0] "He was good for the most part from 95 to 09, which seems like quite a long peak, but you have some really bad performances along the way there + he did not wrestle for entirety of 06 and only had 8 matches in 07. After the Rey feud he has really fallen off quite a bit and in the last decade or so has been an active detriment to the quality of work in companies he wrestled for. The less his AEW run is talked about the better, but let's just say he might be the worst wrestle in the world right now. Overall a very mixed bag of a wrestler."

[5.0] "AM Vision was skinny, had a bitter like look and kinda always a face of muttering agony. He was one of the void effect with Zero tagging up in the NWA battling Arrick Andrews and Gary Valiant. In a TNA Xplosion event featuring Sonny Siaki and Ekmo defeated the team but the only peak for AM as a wrestler was completing against Mike Rapada Jr in 2008 which was the same show where they fought Arrick and Gary."

[6.0] "The peak of his career was in 2000, he became an upper mid card guy when he was with too cool had a great unique look an was very entertaining, , wwf tried to push him to the top card putting him in a program with stone cold the man who ran him down he kind of came up short so true wwf had to get triple h to be the mastermind because rikishi was not on Austins level, after that his career went kind of flat, still better than your average pro wrestler thats why I gave him a six"

[6.0] "Iron Mike Sharpe was a permanent fixture in the WWF's golden and not so golden years. Usually a joy to watch; always growling moaning and bellowing & was often willing to bump around as if stuck in a pinball machine. He was pretty damn big too, all natural, no 'roids here! *takes a powder and goes halfway to the locker room before coming back* Sometimes an episode of Primetime Wrestling feels incomplete without "Canada's Greatest Athlete". I always loved that he was always stuffing LITERALLY NOTHING into his forearm protector. That was All Natural Canadian Maplewood that knocked some of his opponents out! Unfortunately, he had a habit of not working well with some and could drag things way down as a result. 6.25"

[6.0] "Hes a good performer, intense, able to engage the fans but he really, REALLY needs a shake up or a gimmick change. The problem I have with Ilja is that hes interchangeable with Charlie Dempsey or any other strong style superstar in WWE/NXT. Add the fact that Pete Dunne is no longer Butch anymore and the problem is grown. Ilja is fine for now but his character and personality doesn't have any longevity."

[6.0] "I've been enjoying Jack Perry in NJPW recently. I'm not going to comment on the cock-up in AEW last year since it just seemed like a mess on all fronts, but he's clearly a talented dude in ring and on the mic, while only being 26 years old. He's not lighting the world on fire but with him cutting his teeth in Japan now, I see a relatively bright future for Jack Perry. Based on the few solid matches he's already had with the likes of DOUKI, Sanada and RUSH, I'd consider him an above average wrestler worthy of a 6, but I could see this rising soon."

[6.0] "Dale Veasey showed right away he had something going for him. Had one heck of a physique, wonderful timing, notable body control and looked like a somebody for a nobody. Solid, credible heel enhancement talent. His peak was probably in Southwest; there he was finally an upper card heel on Texas All Star Wrestling, it seemed like he found his footing. From here though his career took a downward trajectory and I have to cast blame on his lack of height, as it was VERY obvious. So obvious and so painful, that in Memphis he had a valet "Bambi" and it was hard to tell who was shorter! Then The State Patrol gimmick. It's a shame that he's the one that retired early and his near dead weight tag partner is the one who trained a whole bunch of guys WRONGLY. Something tells me Dale Veasey would have been the better trainer at the Power Plant. 5.5"

[6.0] "From what I have seen she has been mixed, can be quite fun, but also a bit clumsy as well. Still, she has a unique size, which helps her be set apart from the other luchadores in CMLL."

[6.0] "I had to go back and realign my timeline for this guy. Started as "Rick Casey" (in Southwest/Blanchard's territory) the supposed brother of Cowboy Scott Casey. This wasn't a bad start but I'm glad this alternate timeline didn't last. He looked the part, looked great dressed in Scott's gear. Next he debuted in Mid South Wrestling as Wendell Cooley against Ric Flair. Ric Flair could work a four star match with a broom at that point, so he made Wendell look like he belonged. After an immediate fall from potential grace, he earned an underdog tag team championship run with Al Perez and this definitely worked for me. From here he worked in Alabama (as Cooley) & Memphis (as Casey) and did fine in both areas. I thought he would do more in Jim Herd's WCW but, nope. I have to say that I absolutely positively love his look; he has the face of horror film icon Tom Savini and usually he's dressed in ring gear akin to Scott Casey *gush*!"

[6.0] "Punk was one of the OG indie darlings and in some instances a pioneer, but most of his contemporaries in ROH were better than him in-ring. CM Punk shined via his ability to talk and rile up an audience, all while attempting to wrestle like KENTA without ever quite getting there."

[6.0] "Similar to the CM Punk review I made, I think this review might get some people upset, but I genuinely don't care. Overall, Mercedes Mone is a decent talent, she's got a really good move-set, has had some really really good matches with wrestlers like Bayley, Becky Lynch, Charlotte, and Bianca Belair, and is quite popular with wrestling fans. At the same time however, she can be sometimes sloppy in-ring, has a really bad attitude based off reports backstage, and seems to (as someone pointed out on this database page) let fame and her ego get to her head, not to mention that similar to CM Punk fans, her fans can be quite loud and vocal and will always defend her even when she's wrong or did something wrong. When it comes to the 4 horsewomen debate based off talent, I believe Mercedes is the 4th best (yes, I said 4th best) horsewoman when it comes to in-ring and everything else in general minus aura. It's going to be interesting to see how she does in AEW, considering she didn't have a good NJPW run at all and she's coming off a massive knee/ankle injury that could have done massive career-altering damage to her mobility, I guess we'll just have to wait and see. Is she worth that massive paycheck she asked for? I'm not sure about that, but as time goes on, we'll see if she's either a net positive or a net negative to AEW and it's product."

[6.0] "Hito and Masa Sato tag team had good chemistry in the two/three falls hit hard. Fought young Nick Bockwinkel in the early years, battled Pat Patterson & Rocky Johnson. In singles he fought Tim Woods in whoopers and George Wells that took the fans breathe away aftershock of the war."

[6.0] "Nia Jax is incredibly underrated. She does her role well, and women's wrestling in America in general is short on larger wrestlers that can act as powerhouses for others to play off of. She's been good as of late, so as of now I believe a score of satisfactory is more than justified."

[6.0] "I Don't get AEW, most of the time and the women's division certainly doesn't help. 5'2 and skinny vs 5'7 and somewhat muscular, makes no logical sense. Sakazaki doesn't help. I think AEW is about to lose their TV deal, and the fact that WWE and their Women's division is the peak mens attitude era compared to this is insane."

[6.0] "I saw someone claim she was the modern day "Mean Gene" Okerlund. I've never had the laughter I had to that day or since then. They put her on commentary, and I remember the Sabu tweet about "cock-sucking" and now that she hosts "oral sessions" you know i love a good pun."

[6.0] "I thought his initial 2012-2015 WWE run was excellent, but 2016 became quite um bad, and it was his fault, need evidence, his match with Brock Lesnar, and his interview with Steve Austin. I completely get why he left WWE after the whole gas mask nonsense, and I thought he'd do ok in AEW, and he did. and then he got fat, he got slow, and he had some of the WORST matches of all time, that was OUTLAW MUDSHOW GARBAGE BULLSHIT. In the words of CM Punk, he is the third best guy in his own group which seems to be a reoccurring theme in his career."

[6.0] "fun, generic powerhouse. dont mind him on doses but when hes on the mic, its not really the best. like that time he said he was gonna beat Shane McMahon on behalf of all the idiots in the world. I won't blame him for that pandemic world title run because that was a lot to ask outta anyone and it seems like braun was one of the only ones to step up to the plate. but yeah other than that, you usually know what your getting with him. I liked him and ricochet partnering but I think that was a punishment for them both for talking crap on twitter lol"

[6.0] "Mina Shirakawa has improved so much, from being a pretty face in wrestling to somebody who can actually wrestle and put on a good match is a true testament to her as a performer. Still, I can't really rate her higher than a 6 because she's not incredible and is clearly below the level of somebody like Mayu Iwatani, but it's unrealistic to expect all Joshi wrestlers to be on that level."

[6.0] "Eh... he's alright. Not sure why people think he was going to be the next big Mexican wrestler in WWE or anything, he did have a great run in NXT but since then he has done absolutely nothing. His AEW run was a joke, returning to WWE was probably the best thing he ever did but he really needs to figure out a good gimmick because that's what is really holding him back from being memorable."