DeutschEnglish
Not logged in or registered. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Latest Comments

Wrestlers Database

Welcome to our comments page, where you can read all of the comments written by you and other members of the CAGEMATCH community. Please note that while we do our best to ensure that all comments adhere to our community guidelines, this list may still contain some unfiltered content. This may include comments that have been removed by our system or by the CAGEMATCH team for violations of our ratings system rules. Nevertheless, we believe that the comments section is a valuable resource for sharing opinions and feedback on wrestling events, and we encourage you to read and contribute to the discussion.
Month:
Displaying items 51 to 150 of total 1230 items that match the search parameters.
Database:
Inmate:
#DateComment
5101.03.2024
15:30 
MattHall wrote about Chase Tatum:
[1.0] "More less a jobber in WCW, he had the size and look, but didn't far much from anything else. He had a good background in sports, but again that was about it. Might be unfair to rate him very low, but he really didn't do much in his very tiny wrestling career. However Chase Tatum wrestled Goldberg, Scott Steiner, Curt Hennig, and even John Cena!"
5203.03.2024
20:42 
[1.0] "Tremendously horrible, he makes David Arquette look like the nature Ric Flair in WCW 2001 short run. Very very very bad."
5303.03.2024
21:39 
[1.0] "Absolutely horrendous imitation of a wrestler. No sensible character work, idiotic no selling, not fun or funny and makes wrestling look like a childish act. This character and presentation with spot based wrestling without any build may work on the indies but there shouldn't be any room for this crap on national television. There is only "I'm acting like I'm cool but I'm not actually and that's supposed to be fun" attitude and move on move on move action that nobody gets any f'n damage from until the pinfall in every match of this dude, it's a shame that this guy held a title in a major promotion that has countless talent is just sad, it vould've elevated someone can actually help wrestling in the future. But people seem to like it unfortunately and I'll throw my only point for that undeserved popularity, he's just a disgrace for this business and it's legends."
5404.03.2024
05:50 
TessShocker wrote about Eva Marie:
[1.0] "She had all the time in the world to improve after her release, yet she became barely passable for a short match. I understand we are all busy with careers/businesses but girl if you have the time to work out as much as you claim you certainly have the time to find a wrestling school and once a week do your work outs there. I dont want to rate her a 0 but she's pretty close to it."
5504.03.2024
06:02 
[1.0] "I cant believe they put the NXT womens title on her. She doesnt have the look, personality and she's sure as hell not an IMPRESSIVE wrestler. Triple H better get his s--- together and stop calling up and bringing back people who were let go for a reason. She's dead weight. Them not having anything for her but putting her right away as the +1 for another boring character (Candice) proves my point. How long till the division is overloaded with these "amazing technical" wrestlers who have 0 personality, character or a gimmick. Get rid of her Candice, Tegan, Xia, Shayna, Zoey, Scarlet, Piper and Tamina. NXT talent can replace them in the blink of an eye and do a better job for that matter. You want ratings ? Then stop putting on these boring people who make me CHANGE THE CHANNEL!"
5604.03.2024
11:17 
SoaKas wrote about Bryce Remsburg:
[1.0] "Legitimately the worst ref I've ever seen. Normally you would think that a referee can't be as bad as I make him seem to be but Remsburg just seems to want to get himself over. He's not very subtle, his gestures and reactions are too flamboyant in order to be a referee (who's supposed to emit authority). However, the one thing that inspired me to write this review are his three counts when a guy seems to be unconscious. He raises the arm, lets it fall, dramatically yells out "ONE" and then does the thing over and over again. It's impossible to suspend your disbelief that way and it makes the submission move look super dorky."
5705.03.2024
01:02 
[1.0] "I always have respect for people who dare to enter the ring and entertain people at the risk of their health. But like every field, there has to be one that is the worst in its profession, and when I think of wrestling and who would be the worst, I immediately think of Horace. No skills, no charisma, no clue of what he is doing there, and neopotism throwed in here, you got that goofball, turned into an insult to all wretling fans brother."
5806.03.2024
08:31 
BobRosie wrote about Adrianna :
[1.0] "Watching her is like watching a dollar store Nia Jax and Nia is already cheap so that's saying something. Needs more training looks very unsafe, slow and lost in the ring most of the time. Im assuming Mocha44 is either Adrianna or a close friend but they are wrong either way Im not trolling Adrianna is not good at this! All the best to her and hope she improves but present day she is a BAD professional wrestler she has no idea how to structure a professional wrestling match that makes sense! No idea how to tell a story in the ring once the bell rings."
5906.03.2024
11:46 
[1.0] "I will never forgive Mandy for tarnishing the once prestigious NXT Women's Championship. Her seemingly never ending reign did nothing to improve her image. Then she was demanding to give her some "respect" when she was the champion? How can people even respect her if she can't even win on her own? As much as her simps try to tell everyone that she deserves better, Mandy is awful and will forever be a disgrace to the division. I'm glad she got fired and hopefully never comes back. And to all fans of Mandy, remember what AJ Lee said before? 'Talent is not sexually transmitted, ' yeah, reality hurts and Mandy fits that line well lmao."
6006.03.2024
17:50 
[1.0] "Magnum is kind of in a weird spot. He is young, and he only seems to be put in high positions that he does not deserve or have the ability to deliver. He works with people like Marty Scrull which do not help at all. Maybe he will do okay as he gets older, but right now he stands out to me as someone that is just buying his way into things and has earned nothing on his own."
6107.03.2024
17:29 
ClawIzuka wrote about Mike Hart:
[1.0] "I looked it up because I was curious, he is not an actual Hart, but rather a stepson to Smith. Either way, he is one of the Harts that are just bad. He looks like he is not sober and his in ring stuff is laughably bad. If he is getting work off the Hart name, then the promoters kind of deserve it."
6207.03.2024
17:58 
ClawIzuka wrote about Awesome Kong:
[1.0] "I was shocked how Awesome Kong could be rated this low.. then I realized it was someone else, then I remembered who he was. Oh the days where just being large was enough to be on TV."
6307.03.2024
18:05 
ClawIzuka wrote about Big Swole:
[1.0] "I heard a lot of hype behide Swole but never once did I see any of it backed up in the ring. I've seen maybe a dozen Swole matches and every single one was sloppy and uninteresting, she would just hit her flurry of offence with no real reason to any of it."
6407.03.2024
23:23 
[1.0] "Genuinely just insanely forgettable. I can't name a more forgettable wrestler out there - every time he shows up on-screen, I genuinely forgot he ever existed. And he was the same exact way when I first saw him, back in NJPW and Impact! Outside of his forgettable on-screen appearance, he just doesn't have good matches - not a single match of his is better than somewhat adequate outside of his NJPW matches which, let's face it, are because of the opponent he's going up against. It's obviously he wants to be on the level of Big Van Vader or Big Bam Bigelow, but really all he is as a wrestler is if Earthquake didn't have an memorable gimmick. I would LOVE to be proven wrong on him and I hope I am, but for right now he's remarkably forgettable... which I consider almost worse than just being a "bad" wrestler, especially in the WWE."
6509.03.2024
02:16 
[1.0] "New Jack was not a wrestler, he was a street fighter. But if he actually qualifies as a wrestler then he was one of the worst wrestlers ever. It takes skill to learn how to properly execute grapples, submission moves and strikes. It takes little talent or skill to attack people with weapons. On top of that he wasn't safe to work with at all and tried to kill people in the ring for no reason. If you like senseless violence or outlaw mudshows then you might like New Jack but if you like wrestling you'd probably be turned off by his matches. But I give him a point for being good on the mic."
6611.03.2024
04:20 
[1.0] "Orange Cassidy's gimmick is seriously not for me. What makes a good wrestling match, in my mind, is when the wrestlers put on a performance that makes it believable that they actually want to hurt each other. In the case of Orange Cassidy, everyone he loses to looks terrible because they were somehow unable to pin someone down for three seconds when he had his hands in his pockets for most of the match. Comedy wrestling can be good when the person working the gimmick is an actual underdog, but not when they are winning week in and week out. In every Orange Cassidy match the joke is actually on the audience, the message being conveyed is "look how phoney we can make this and you chumps won't change the channel." If I attended an indie show, and was one of 30 total people in the crowd and this was the slop they expected to shovel down our throats I would want my money. I don't hate the actual person, he is making a living and doing the things that a certain segment of the wrestling audience wants to see. Just keep it off of my TV, thank you."
6711.03.2024
23:00 
SethyBoy wrote about Liv Morgan:
[1.0] "Liv Morgan is overhyped imo. She hasn't had any notable matches that involved her and someone else, they all included a star who carried the match. Liv should not be close to the top of WWE."
6813.03.2024
01:51 
TessShocker wrote about Ava :
[1.0] "Absolute flop, for the time she has been there she should've already debuted on the main roster but she can't even have a 4 min decent match. Rock's daughter, what a draw... They keep kissing his azz as if he's done something relevant for them this year.... How many more boring Samoans we need. Reigns wasn't enough, so have nia, tamina, that solo loser and now her..... What a draw. I skip them every time they are on tv. Oh also i forgot to mention there are complete new girls that have had 0 exposure to wrestling before and they wrestle 100 times better than her. Not to mention she looks like she's smelling her own fart all the time."
6913.03.2024
01:53 
TessShocker wrote about B-Fab:
[1.0] "B-Gone ! She showed some potential in NXT in her no DQ match but that was it. Since then she hasnt improved at all in fact she has regressed. Compared to someone like Maxine who improved leaps and bounds. She isnt wrestling and in the rare occasion when they let her do something she flops and fails. Her entire staple is awful not just her. Vince let them go for a reason. And Hunter filled up the roster with rejects and flops nobody wants to see... Edit: Now she's a read head to pay homage to her idol Eva Marie from one botch queen to another!"
7013.03.2024
15:28 
[1.0] "This guy couldn't wrestle and his finisher looked weak. He played one of the least memorable monster heel characters of all time, and that's not to mention the fact that he had the charisma of a frayed toothbrush. Snitsky was also overpushed like a lot of big guys were at the time and involved in some incredibly ridiculous storylines for some reason, turning him into a joke. He was so slow and bad in the ring that he makes Big Show seem entertaining."
7113.03.2024
17:35 
[1.0] "Kevin Patrick as a color commentator was absolutely awful. at the commentary table, he sounded like a child-like Sheamus and was just unbearable to listen to. I will give him one point however for him being a backstage interviewer, which he was fine in, nothing special however as the likes of Kayla Braxton are way better at that."
7214.03.2024
23:41 
TallNick2 wrote about Tyrus:
[1.0] "Absolutely horrid worker, can hardly wrestle being an immobile big guy throughout his career with seemingly no prime, just a continuous fall in quality (which wasn't that good to start with), his NWA title reign shat on the legacy of that belt. He gets a single point getting somewhat over with his dancing gimmick but even then that was pretty poor."
7315.03.2024
19:02 
thedman0310 wrote about Gunner:
[1.0] "This lunk was absolutely useless everywhere he went. He dragged down everyone he worked with in TNA and got Steve Maclin and Westin Blake pulled from TV because he was a racist idiot on social media. But sure, WWE kept him another year after firing Blake and Maclin. Thank god he's retired so no one has to see him stink up a ring ever again."
7417.03.2024
01:18 
[1.0] "I came to bury Nia Jax because she's a botch machine who has proven for 8 straight years that she can't wrestle. No idea why she got pushed so much before getting fired other than her size and intensity similar to every big man wrestler. She's like Awesome Kong without the skills and all her fans were marks. You'd think someone with 8 years of experience would know how to do their job. No idea why WWE would invest so much money in a wrestler who was a liability to any wrestler she worked with."
7518.03.2024
06:56 
[1.0] "A singular point for the fact he had *some* good ideas. He wasn't 100% god fucking awful, just 99%. He absolutely did book a couple shows that were actually good, and he did always make sure everyone on the roster had something to do. That being said, he didn't understand wrestling in its basic fundamentals, and most of his story lines were in poor taste at best. I understand 25 years ago was a very different time than it is now, and during that time sexism, misogyny, homophobia, transphobia, drag-bashing, racism, and honestly any form of bigotry wasn't taken as seriously as it is now, and was used for comedic effect or something along those lines, but considering it wasn't even good back then, I think it's fair for me to put serious criticism on the man for incorporating that so much, especially towards his bashing of women in storylines. It's not a coincidence how many times he's painted women as liars of abuse and pregnancies, as well as being unfaithful. Asides from how deeply offensive a lot of his booking was in that aspect, he also quite literally didn't understand what makes wrestling actually captivating. Take a look at his WCW work for instance, where every match on the show contained a ref bump, interference on top of interference, constant bending to flat out breaking of the rules, and nonsensical booking in terms of who goes over who, without any form of consistency or flow. Gimmick matches should be a special occasion, not something that takes a majority of the show's card. Asides from his awful booking and writing, he was also a damn terrible character. Absolutely unbearable, especially in WCW. 1 point for Survivor Series 1998, that's literally all he's got."
7618.03.2024
21:31 
TrashBoat182 wrote about Gunner:
[1.0] "Poor quality wrestler, poor quality views, not really worth being booked again, won't really be missed ? Bog standard in the ring, bog standard on the mic, bog standard human, what else is there to say really...the fact he was pushed as a face is also a reflection on some of vinces worst ideas"
7719.03.2024
21:05 
[1.0] "Eww. Her look is so bad i can never get behind that. She's what in the business they call a channel changer. Her work in NXT was nothing to write home about. The only good thing i remember he with is her 2 on 1 matches. And even then the jobbers had better gear than her. The jobbers looked like the signed talent not her... That's sad. OMG and can you imagine Indi and her in a tag team on the main roster.... most boring tag team in the history of wrestling? And if someone explains to me what business he has being Ryder's valet on the indies, i'll be in awe."
7819.03.2024
21:16 
[1.0] "I dont know what her deal was, if she wanted to be a legit wrestler or just a manger and they put her in that match just bc they needed someone for the tournament brackets, but the only match she has, she really didnt do anything. Had a cute look back then tho. Now i googled her and she looks surgically repaired to put it lightly."
7923.03.2024
13:32 
[1.0] "Rating her as a wrestler, and not as a manager. I don't give 1 ratings lightly, so I first took a look at the other wrestlers I have given a similar score to and decided whether she is a better wrestler than any of them, and the answer was clearly no. Maxxine Dupri has probably been training to wrestler for at least a year, but her level of skill is still far, far below the level of talent that would be expected of even someone on NXT Level Up. It doesn't make sense to me why the WWE is having her wrestle on the main roster, where she clearly stands out for her lack of talent."
8024.03.2024
12:19 
[1.0] "I have said this to friends. The way I view Blake Christian is thisHe is the wrestler that people think the young bucks and Will Ospreay are. Theres no psychology in his work. He does moves that make zero to no sense because all they are really is flips with no real point in happening, he does those flips welll but thats it really, He did a heat spot in Germany where he went for a dive, didnt actually do it to get heat, he got no reaction and then did the dive anyways. He has no connection with the crowd and I would rather have anyone else as GCW champion."
8124.03.2024
21:53 
CDProsPro wrote about Brad Maddox:
[1.0] "Brad Maddox is lass short of a few Bob since his only fans experiment defined his career back in 2015. His abilities in his wrestling career was bad to the point he became a main event ref for 2 months, plain Jane look and no gimmick or class. Brad seriously made a massive error in his life by wasting his FCW career, wasting his TV experience on being a second rate Eric Bischoff knock off. No other character in WWE barely had an impact after his run was up. Brad is a sad pathetic little man who cannot grasp the fact order management exists."
8225.03.2024
08:46 
[1.0] "Of all the wrestlers that have ever existed, Beau James in undisputedly one of them. No living or dead human being can doubt that he has in fact wrestled for many years. He's booked several very good wrestlers for his flea market-level promotion over those years. However, he is total shit in the ring, as a personality, and as a representative of southern professional wrestling. Please Beau away."
8325.03.2024
14:52 
[1.0] "He was never an accomplished wrestler and lacked charisma when speaking on a microphone. It's unclear how he landed a job as a trainer on Tough Enough, as he didn't seem to have the qualifications to train anyone. He was never a big name in either WCW or WWE, so I feel like he was an odd choice. After learning about his unpleasant behavior behind the scenes, I'm relieved they fired him."
8426.03.2024
05:32 
yenada wrote about Erfie:
[1.0] "No offense, but Erfie really needs a lot of improvement. My rating is very harsh, I know, but honestly Erfie really has a lot of issues. His in ring ability is not there, his moves don't connect, lots of botches and from the few matches I've seen no pscyhology. He's found a decent character (though I'm not a fan of this kind of character) but he doens't even know how to pull it off. Terrible on the microphone, mumbles and comes across as a child. His gear is nice but he has the physique of an 11 year old. It's straight up unrealistic when you see him take down someone else. I saw him live at SPW X and looked like a lost child. He NEEDS to improve on the mic. If your gimmick is so eccentric and you can barely wrestle you better be able to cover it with mic skills, if you can't unfortunautely 1/10 is the rating."
8526.03.2024
14:48 
ClawIzuka wrote about Lexis King:
[1.0] "His AEW run always felt completely unearned and that he was only there because of his name. Never saw a match that remotely interested me and it seems like his only moment of relevance was when he let MJF insult his dark past which is just not very interesting wrestling content. I have seen about 20 seconds of Lexis King because I just cannot be bothered to watch him."
8626.03.2024
21:24 
[1.0] "Maybe the most annoying ring announcer ever. She represents perfectly all these young and beautiful girl put here just because they are beautiful. Im afraid that the times with Mean Gene, Justin Roberts (in WWE) or Tony Chimel is over and that we have now horrible announcers forcing on their voices such as Irvin, Alicia Taylor or Hamilton. Shootout to Byron Saxon who were great in Saudi Arabia simply because he wasnt forcing on his voice to look impressive such as Samantha Irvin. Just try to be natural, maybe it will be better"
8726.03.2024
22:25 
[1.0] "I used to like him a ton, but he's really fallen off and is just a massive fucking joke these days. A great manager and promoter who was fantastic on the mic has turned onto an immature bigoted asshole who just hates on pretty much anything because he's so focused on the old days. I totally get the perspective of trying to keep some form of realism in professional wrestling, but to cry bloody murder because of comedy wrestling or wrestling these days has more high flying and whatnot is just absurd. Not only that, he's misogynistic and a massive racist. Comments about Joshi wrestling is the biggest example in terms of the latter. The most recent heinous thing he has done is his comments about the Janel Grant allegations and lawsuit from earlier this year. Regardless of it being confirmed or not, you don't fucking make jokes about that shit."
88today
00:49 
CDProsPro wrote about Rita Stone:
[1.0] "Incredibly plain with predictable results in execution wise. She seems very good upon the eyes but as far as ability in the ring is concerned, she barely compute all areas of combat or aesthetic choreography. Not Jenna Morasca bad and yet far away from Becky Lynch. Some fans think she is a fan but clearly only a fan by default. Not sure if she is in it for the business or if she can live out her dream as a stiff ironing board. Awww shucks but it is an opinion. Maybe she might improve in the ring but as a person she is off."
89today
02:56 
[1.0] "Mandy was not that good in the ring and the fact she had such a long reign as NXT Women's champion was mind-boggling... In the ring she had a limited move-set and the moves she did just didn't look good; she focused so much on her looks when she should've focused on getting better in the ring, she always, in my opinion, looked scared to take a good bump and that held her back. I will always believe that she and Sonya should've held the tag team championships at some point, I was never really a fan of them, but they deserved at least one reign. When she went back to NXT and formed Toxic Attraction I thought she would've reignited a fire for supporting her, but she just became unbearable and over-pushed."
90today
03:03 
[1.0] "Indi is one of the worst wrestlers on the roster and that's saying something considering there's new NXT people with zero experience. Her moves are slow and look bad and her timing seems off most of the time. Her run as NXT Women's Champion was a waste, they only gave it to her because she was an NXT vet and then proceeded to get called up and is just there, not doing anything. Maybe she'll get better with some more main roster experience... but I doubt it. Candice needs to drop Indi and Indi needs to find something new to do, maybe check out NXT again or get some matches on Main Event to improve because with the rate she's going now, she's going to get left in catering while Candice shines in the spotlight."
9101.03.2024
05:37 
Pertinax wrote about Xyon Quinn:
[2.0] "Has a great 'look' for professional wrestling but that's about it. He can't work worth a lick and when NXT 2.0 tried to have him show character, it flopped miserably. Maybe more time at the PC will help but guy is also already 34 so it's probable that he just doesn't have it."
9202.03.2024
01:29 
[2.0] "I feel really bad for Jorge because he was a giant without much atheticism; since the very start it feels like every part of his life was him being picked out for his size then getting injured shortly after before being dropped. He was simply too tall and lanky to really be effective at anything without something coming off the hinges. Oh, and he ALSO had terrible diabetes to boot alongside all of that which made him even more inconsistent. He was more or less purely there as a attraction more than anything else, but once the allure of that wore off his wrestling just wasn't anything good at all. The guy clearly at least was trying but his body never seemed to follow whatever he was trying to do from the very limited moveset that he had. Watching him at the very end of his career where he couldn't even do anything bar lean off the ropes and have someone hit him is probably top 5 in the saddest things I've seen in a wrestling ring. Apparently he was a pretty nice guy (to his detriment in places) and the fact that he was committed enough to go to Japan to improve his wrestling skills is proof enough that he was definitely passionate about the business. He just sucked at it."
9306.03.2024
01:25 
[2.0] "I am sorry, like yeah she is an average in-ring performer, but it seems that she feels to be like the center of the female wrestling, when she is not. She is an injury prone as well. As far as I know she was supposed to be the next "big thing" in Stardom, and NJPW, and what came up from that? Nothing... she injured herself and got back to the United States after failing to become someone relevant in the japanese wresling industry, where she was a nobody and there were better performers than her. Appart from that, she is always showing an arrogant attitude towards everything that makes you dislike her as a performer and as a person. I heard she is going to AEW, certainly in WWE she is not necessary anymore, new faces have surpassed her there. At the early stages of her career she seemed to be someone who loved the wrestling industry not mattering what, after gaining popularity she turned into an arrogant brat who cared more about the money than wrestling itself. Fame invaded her head."
9406.03.2024
01:42 
JulianPera50 wrote about Julissa :
[2.0] "Pfff, she is my compatriot from Mexico and I feel guilty for getting dirty with her, but good lord, she was not released by WWE, she asked for her release because she felt "not having the proper treatment". She was in a tag team with Valentina Feroz, that in some sort of way could have worked if they had changed a bit and added more charisma, new attires IDK. She didn't cared for Valentina, even though they shared lots of instagram posts together being "friends". She left her for her own luck, and since then she has never been seen on television, I wouldn't be surprised if WWE releases her. She came back to Mexico for competing on The Crash promotion, where not even one month after arriving, she won the Crash Women's Championship. Guess what? her father is a former wrestler called Bronco, who helped her with contacts to give her the title and promote her a lot for the promotion. However, Mexican fans haven't bought her as an entertaining wrestler, which led to most of the events where she was promoted as "the big star former WWE wrestler", to be a complete flop with very few tickets sold. Another wrestler whose fame went to her head.""
9506.03.2024
17:57 
ClawIzuka wrote about Kobe Durst:
[2.0] "I was never sure about Kobe. He came off like someone who saw Joey Janela get popular by doing crazy stuff and just tried to mimick him. His in ring style always looked like he tried to be intense but had such a childlike face it always seemed weird. I normally would rate him average, but then seeing him fall from grace for some dumb comments on social media and then basically disapear from any legitimate promotion made me think a lot less of him."
9606.03.2024
23:36 
[2.0] "Mike Rotunda is one of the most boring wrestlers I have ever seen. he's a bad promo, but not in a way like Sid Vicious or Von Wagner where it loops around to being funny, he's just dry and charismaless. His in-ring work is also incredibly dull, lots of crappy looking holds, basic moves and a lack of fluidity that makes him just so boring. IRS was a shit gimmick and you cannot convince me otherwise, how this man gave us Bray Wyatt is beyond me, with his captivating drawl that drew in wrestling fans young and old, with such a creative mind that really thought outside of the box about what wrestling can present (RIP), and even Bo Dallas was charismatic (I still Bo-lieve)"
9707.03.2024
00:38 
KM72 wrote about Maxxine Dupri:
[2.0] "Maxxine is not a good wrestler in any way shape or form. She has little to nothing to offer from a character perspective. she's not a good promo. And when it comes to her in-ring work it is horrible, littered with botches and miscommunications. In the Royal Rumble she botched just about every spot she had. In the tag match with Akira Tozawa vs Ivar and Valhalla the most memorable moment was her botching a move in the corner. she should be sent back to NXT and learn and get better or go back to being a manager"
9807.03.2024
16:30 
[2.0] "He's very athletic. There's no denying that. The problem is nothing he does ever makes any sense. Doing the "I'm crazy" circling hand gesture, sticking your tongue out, and jumping from heights doesn't make you good or interesting. He's the epitome of doing moves just to do them. He also can't cut a good promo and if the reports are to be believed, is a a manchild behind the scenes as well. He's severely injured both Matt and Jeff Hardy, made his private life public and then asked for privacy in his new relationship while also making that public as well. He has negative charisma and should be released."
9907.03.2024
17:30 
[2.0] "Looks like she has zero personality. The only real asset is the look but I've seen the odd match and it looks like she is just thrown out there with no idea what to do. Not sure why people use her as a valet as she doesn't add anything."
10007.03.2024
17:44 
[2.0] "One of the most unlikeable wrestlers I've ever seen. His best matches are him receiving a pasting by the other guy and his worst matches are when I'm supposed to root for him. I just can't do it. He's such a vile man. His offense is insane but it's tainted cause I can't enjoy any of it because of the person performing. Sometimes if you turn your brain off it's cool though. The man should be a contender at best and never hold the gold of a promotion. He's too unreliable and also not very bright. He's had plenty of good matches but those are less common nowadays. Bad wrestler overall. I think the real reason why I dislike Will is because like MJF I never feel an authentic aura of someone wrestling in a struggle but rather a person playing a performative piece. As an example Terry Funk I believe when he wrestled he was crazy, but with Will, I don't get any of that just some dummy doing cool moves and giving weird facials. I know he can sell and work over a limb and he's fine doing those things, but as time has gone on and he's been put in more positions of power in different companies with no one to correct him I feel he's gotten even more performative."
10107.03.2024
17:51 
ClawIzuka wrote about Bruno Sassi:
[2.0] "I have no idea why TNA brought these guys in. The weird part, at the time I was so high on TNA that I was willing to accept anybody they used. Unfortunately... ya it was not good and I was an idiot back then."
10207.03.2024
19:19 
ClawIzuka wrote about Jack Vaughn:
[2.0] "I've seen his videos and checked out some matches. For a guy who complains about modern indy wrestlers (though he may have a point), its not like he backs up his style in the ring. I think the only reason people are giving him anything is because he is doing exactly what he complains about, exposing the business for popularity. Maybe it's all just a work but if it is.. it's still not good."
10307.03.2024
22:11 
[2.0] "He did a bunch of moves and argued with a lot of people on twitter. Trying to give him a fair ranking is hard because the personal stuff literally derailed his entire career, and even his career was kind of in a bubble because for some reason NJPW was still willing to use him after a bunch of other incidents. Heard he tried to make a comeback and instantly started social media fights with people because they didn't want to be on shows with him. I think the Elign or whatever his name is now exerperiment is over."
10407.03.2024
22:14 
ClawIzuka wrote about JD McDonagh:
[2.0] "Its amazing that some people will get fired for personal issues and others just get renamed and continue to be on TV despite offering nothing. Massively overated and I have no idea why, he doesn't add anything and really is just there for a fall guy, but not even an interesting fall guy."
10507.03.2024
22:30 
ClawIzuka wrote about Kongo Kong:
[2.0] "He's big... and apparently not a very good person. Maybe he would have succeeded in the early 90's where being just big was enough, but its not enough in the modern era. Maybe he was better before based on the ratings here but I don't see any of it."
10608.03.2024
12:39 
Kash wrote about Angelica Dante:
[2.0] "Mere eye-candy. Never pulled a match, never got involved in physical in-ring action, never laid or received a chop, never took the mic (which, you'll agree, is quite problematic for a manager)... her only added value's posing naked on instagram... Please, David McLane, have her speak or leave. Explain us what, exactly, her purpose is beside showing thighs, womb and cleavage while accompanying Chainsaw to the ring ? Enough naked bimbos and duckfacing airheads : give us women that have some reason to be in a pro wrestling ring !"
10709.03.2024
03:40 
[2.0] "He was a below average wrestler mostly known for being in tough enough and now it turns out he also punched a guy to death in a violent rage. Not much to take in there. He looked okay. He could play a sort of okay heel. His mic skills in deep south wrestling were okay, but he ultimately lacked the drive to be a pro wrestler despite being offered paid training."
10809.03.2024
16:40 
[2.0] "Lars Sullivan was a believable wrestler in terms of strength, but that is all that I can think of when remembering him. Besides his crazy strength, Lars didn't have ANY redeeming qualities as a wrestler, no mic skills, no charisma, just your "average" powerhouse wrestler who couldn't do what most wrestlers should be able to do. Lars was also hyped up a lot before making his main roster WWE debut, which fell flat on it's face, not to mention that he had some serious accusations made against him which ultimately ended up destroying his career. For someone that was hyped to the moon a few years ago, he sure ended up being a massive bust."
10909.03.2024
22:05 
Odinohka wrote about Zelina Vega:
[2.0] "Zelina was an incredible manager when she accompanied Andrade: good acting, funny, intense, involved. However, Zelina is a poor wrestler. Limited, her in-ring lacks impact, she is slow, not physically impressive, not very athletic. In addition, his character is bland and has lost his splendor. I don't understand the hype behind her. On the other hand, I really like her outfits, and if you add a little bit of history behind her character, she could becomes again an interesting manager or a cool heel mid-card opponent."
11010.03.2024
09:43 
[2.0] "While it felt a bit harsh to hear Tony Khan talk trash about him so publicly, Jinder Mahal can arguably seen as the worst world champion in WWE history. Going from jobber to world champ in a matter of weeks did him no favours as no one bought his quick rise to the top as nothing more as a ploy to advertise to the Indian community, which was unsuccessful to boot. People often compare his run to JBL's, and though I do not like JBL as a person, he wasn't a jobber before his run and he had memorable fueds during his reign. If they had given him a run with the US title instead, then maybe most people wouldn't look back at hi9m so negatively, but in the end of the day, Jinder Mahal will never be seen as a credible threat to the main event picture again."
11110.03.2024
18:06 
[2.0] "Admittedly, early in his career, he wasn't exactly terrible, being one of those more mobile big men types, sorta like Earthquake, although he was still awkward in some areas. However, as soon as the late 90s rolled around, the guy became borderline immobile, barely being able to walk, couldn't run at all (simply only able to walk fast), and needing the ropes to help him get off the mat. Not to mention, his physique made it so it look like he would blow up at any moment, and things he was already awkward at (such as selling) was made even worse. I'll give him one point since he wasn't completely horrible in his first few years, and another for the novelty of a 600+ pound man in a hardcore match, but he's a pretty piss poor big man otherwise. Also, for the curious, it appears he isn't actually Haystacks Calhoun's actual son."
11210.03.2024
22:26 
CDProsPro wrote about Matrox:
[2.0] "This man wrestled as a second job or a hobby. Matrox is his name and his look is lame. Tend towards the skills of shock factor."
11310.03.2024
22:34 
[2.0] "Viscera basically encompassed everything that made big wrestlers terrible throughout WWE history. He was slow, boring, and couldn't wrestle. He had a history of injuring people and even once pissed off the Undertaker. He had some charisma though and I found him sort of enjoyable to watch in the ministry of darkness. The Big Daddy V gimmick was horrible though."
11410.03.2024
23:32 
Zak22 wrote about Kane:
[2.0] "Lumbering, slow, boring wrestler. One of the absolute most overrated wrestlers of all time. His matches with the Undertaker, which in theory should be his best matches were poor as hell, just dull. Even when he was tagging with Undertaker or Daniel Bryant or Rob Van Dam, he was just so damn boring, he bought other people down as a result. I don't understand his high rating at all, call me a hater but I don't get it. I don't think there is a Kane or Isaac Yankem singles match that I've ever really enjoyed. To credit him, his initial reveal as the brother of the undertaker was very good and deserves to be iconic but in ring he lets it all down. He is among the worst WWE champions ever in my honest opinion. And the last decade of his career was largely pointless."
11511.03.2024
09:53 
jameOP81 wrote about The Miz:
[2.0] "A wrestler so hated, he became underrated in the eyes of some, and is now quite possibly the most overrated wrestler on the planet right next to Will Ospreay and Seth Rollins. Completely uninteresting wrestler, a promo that, whilst unique in delivery, is still just as shallow and barren as every other WWE wrestler of his era, a seeming lack of chemistry with every single other person he's ever stepped in the ring with apart from Ziggler for whatever reason, and most damning of all, is that he's all these things, and he simply will not go away. His moveset is crap too. Like if an AI was asked to make a heel wrestler and it was given life afterwards."
11611.03.2024
17:19 
[2.0] "An incredibly annoying personality on TV. Vickie Guerrero redefined how to be annoying to no ends and made the product less fun to watch from time to time. She adds NO value whatsoever to any product and is really only still relevant because she once dated Eddie Guerrero, who is a legend and an all time great wrestler worthy of respect. A majority of the heat Vickie got during her time in wrestling was 'Go-Away' heat since most fans didn't want her around their TV screens nor on TV period. The two points I gave are for her time as an Authority Figure GM, which wasn't bad but certainly nowhere near as good as the likes of Teddy Long and Eric Bischoff."
11711.03.2024
22:24 
[2.0] "character yes. JBL gimmick did what it was supposed to do however his in ring work as a single star is pretty lackluster. The fact how WWE pushed him as a top guy really is confusing considering in my eyes he's always a mid-carder. His stuff in the APA was solid however as an in-ring worker he really just was used and viewed as a WWE ripoff of All Japan's big gaijin man that is 'Stan Hansen' and as said that style of work was definitely not appreciated the same mid 2000s when WWE had seemingly everyone and I just feel like there was better wrestlers in ring that could have surpassed JBL in his role"
11812.03.2024
13:00 
Conquistador37 wrote about Nailz:
[2.0] "So imagine this, I came to rate this turd in the territories called "Thor" and it turned out to be, *THIS GUY*. He sooo SO SUCKED. Notably garbage but could somehow bump. He then moved on to be "Kevin Kelly" and The (Midnight) Rockers could get something watchable out of the guy. The (Midnight) Rockers could make dust collecting fun to watch. Still though, Sherri Martel was there too and she also can make anything fun. Then, "Nailz". EDIT: I dug deep and decided to watch more of his peak; his time in the AWA isn't horrible. The "Mr. Magnificent" stuff was good enough to not be outright insulting. With this new revelation, let's do some math. Thor = 0, "Mr. Magnificent" Kevin Kelly = 4.75, Nailz/The Prisoner = 0. Leaving us with a 1.58 rounded up. (I originally rated him a 1)"
11913.03.2024
01:39 
[2.0] "I don't feel her. She debuted along the likes of Kelani, Izzy, Carmen and even before Bryn but she didn't feel ready and didn't impress me with anything. She felt basic. I hope she improves but for now a 2."
12013.03.2024
14:57 
[2.0] "One of if not the most unmemorable wrestlers of all time. He was a jobber on Smackdown for a minute. Despite being enhancement talent he was incredibly limited as a wrestler and he had almost as little charisma as the Gymini brothers."
12113.03.2024
16:02 
CoopyHoncho wrote about Solo Sikoa:
[2.0] "There's worse wrestlers at present but not many. They're trying to hard to make him like Umaga but he looks as threatening as a box of kittens. He's 30, (as of this review), and has all the presence of someone just getting started. That's bad. John Cena did his best but getting wins over Cena now is shockingly like Ric Flair getting pinned in the mid-2000's. It happens so much it doesn't mean anything. At present he's in the position Dominick Mysterio was before the heel turn. The perfect example of "I'm on the team because my dad is the coach". I'm not sure what Jacob Fatu doesn't have that WWE thinks Solo does. It can only be summed up by family tree."
12213.03.2024
16:26 
[2.0] "I gave her a fair chance in AEW because she was being brought along slowly. Putting a new championship on her was a bad idea. Not even in hindsight but at the time too. She had not proven she was capable of being a champion. Her time in WWE hasn't done much for her either so far. She's been there since last fall and other than walking out and waving and showing up at the Rumble. She hasn't had a match before or since. Something has to give eventually because not even being on NXT is a sign that WWE thinks she's incompetent."
12314.03.2024
16:34 
[2.0] "For as great a manager as he was in the 80's and 90's, he's that much worse as the wrestling talking head version of Ben Shapiro. Someone who exists only to get easily fleeced rubes to part with their money and give him online engagement. I will say, he's enjoyable on Dark Side of the Ring because he's a fan first and has a passion for the business. He also has the emotional maturity of a drunk 6 year old and wishes death on people because they either disagree with him, Russo, or exist, Kenny Omega. There's only so much you separate from inside and outside the ring and his behavior in recent years has severely tarnished his legacy."
12414.03.2024
23:23 
[2.0] "Raquel is a 5x Tag Team champion (NXT & Main Roster) yet she is the least memorable part of all of these reigns. Aliyah, Liv & Dakota all outsold her and are far better in-ring than her and have more charisma and character (yes even Aliyah). Since she's been on the main roster she's just not been that important of a character in other people's stories and I don't think she will amount to a big figure in the women's division. She still has no character even after nine years of wrestling, sorry but smiling and flexing your back muscles isn't a character... She's had a few good matches, but I feel like they were mostly carried by her opponents. If she gets an actual character and maybe a heel turn then I think Raquel will get more over with the fans and be a bigger star that they want her to be."
12515.03.2024
22:00 
[2.0] "Slaughter was a bad worker, even for the lower standards of the time he was active. Plodding, jobber moveset and physice that was chubby at the best of times. He could cut a decent promo but that's it. The most successful run of his career is his Iraqi heel run which was in such poor taste, imagine if WWE pulled this shit in 2022 with the Russia-Ukraine War. Also he never served in the military at any point of his life, so him continuing to live the gimmick is super disrespectful, and I'm not even a big "respect the troops" person. Either way everything about him is just really gross"
12615.03.2024
22:54 
[2.0] "Occasionally okay in the ring with the right opponent, but often looks like a deer in headlights when she's wrestling. Always found her promos annoying, she works better as a heel in my eyes. But the worst part about her, to me, is the situation with Thunder Rosa. I never felt she was the pinnacle of the division, but how she treats her fellow coworkers is worth docking some points, especially since Rosa's one of the only 2 workers that made me invested in a Britt match."
12715.03.2024
23:42 
OKZ Will wrote about Ren Narita:
[2.0] "Ren is a competent worker. That is about the best that can be said about him. He performs moves well. He can't talk. He dresses like a young lion. His offense is drab and uninspired. He doesn't seem to have come up with a single fun sequence, let alone a high spot. As a Shibata clone he was unconvincing, and as an EVIL protege he is unwanted. He is currently more deserving of a pink slip than a push, and really needs to start proving his worth."
12816.03.2024
18:46 
[2.0] "As a valet she was good. As a wrestler she was horrible and needed to find a different role, and it seems like she did because she suddenly disappeared after barely wrestling in the indie circuit. Hopefully whatever she's doing now she's better at."
12916.03.2024
18:50 
[2.0] "Kelly Kelly couldn't wrestle but she looked good and people like seeing hot girls on their screen. She was a gorgeous blonde similar to Torrie Wilson but with less experience. She was around during the era where women wrestlers were called divas and seen as nothing more than sexy eye candy to be gawked at and objectified by men who would routinely have 5 minute matches where that played out like awkward middle school catfights and the lingerie matches were just ridiculous along with the other absurd stunts these women had to perform to get a rise of out a cheap crowd and please that sexual degenerate Vince McMahon. Thankfully nowadays female wrestlers in the WWE are actually trained on how to wrestle."
13017.03.2024
17:09 
[2.0] "I was never a fan of Alberto, whether he was in IMPACT or WWE, I never really cared about about him or his character. He is an "Okay" in ring worker at best and is easily one of the worst wrestlers ever when it comes to who he is as a person. I believe Alberto should just retire as he is never talked about outside of his mediocre run in the WWE.His attempted comeback in IMPACT was just tragic, and his current run in AAA is not talked about. Alberto is forgettable and rightfully so. He should not be wrestling and should go into retirement as not many people care about him at all anymore. 2/10"
13119.03.2024
01:28 
[2.0] "Boring wrestler, no charisma, subpar in-ring skills. Man's entire gimmick and purpose is literallly just "I'm very big". Aside from being one of Brock Lesnar's henchmen for a brief period he was extremely forgettable and had no personality. Only geezers want to see 6 ft 8 and taller guys wrestle. The only thing he had going for him was strength and an intimidating look. No personality, just loootsa strenghth. It's a miracle he got fired."
13219.03.2024
20:42 
[2.0] "Bye, Ronnie. Thank you, not thank you. I've always hated when outsiders come to WWE and try to play wrestlers. She never became more than just the UFC fighter that was handed everything just because she was famous. She didnt connect with the regular fans and to be honest really wasnt anything special. She used to forget her promo lines, get flustered, not be aware of what have to do. She didnt had a character pass her UFC figher... Her promos were not memorable, nor her reigns. I truly hated the time she was in there. I hope she doesnt step foot again in the WWE. Im rating her a 2 because surprisingly she was decent in the ring. Her in ring work was ok."
13319.03.2024
20:49 
[2.0] "Beyond over rated. She only has a good physique and that about it. Her matches are short and she still botches to this day, it is beyond me how someone that's front and center would not take the time to actually go somewhere (not once or twice) and LEARN to properly wrestle. I dont respect the fact that she went back to a company that didnt want her to begin with and ditched the one that actually made her a "star" and im using this term loosely because it is just wrestling and really nobody gives a sh about her outside of it. Enjoy WWE either they will ruin you or you will take the time from their home grown talent and you will make them look like a joke having to sell for your green behind. Either way it is a lose, lose situation. Also she botched twice at the rumble. A spot with Naomi when Jade was the one kicking and a spot with Liv where Liv had to tell her to spot so the whole thing didnt crash and burn. She is not build to be a wrestler. Cant wait to watch her botch, we all need our comedy spots, especially if Nia is gonna be her first program, lol."
13420.03.2024
14:27 
[2.0] "A decent look but the basics was so far off. He cannot work but you can say he is getting better work now at 2024 than a wrestler in 2014."
13523.03.2024
11:12 
[2.0] "This guy has no chance in the main roster with his current act. i know it's meant to be silly and funny, and old school, but it's not the good old school i like, it's outdated things we need to move from yelling to bear claws. He has the decent look of a giant, but clear to be another fail giant like Shanky. Not even his ring work is compelling which is a shame and for the focus, it was wasted goods with the Breakout Tournament."
13623.03.2024
11:56 
vectorx01 wrote about Jade Cargill:
[2.0] "I really don't get the hype around her aside from looking like a "mega star", she's extremely overrated in my eyes, very green in the ring, unintresting in the mic and often resorts to cussing to make herself look gag-worthy. Even Liv Morgan had to carry her in her rumble debut."
13723.03.2024
12:43 
Kash wrote about GenoCyd:
[2.0] "a competent wrestler with an awful attitude, both in and out of the ring. Often incorrect, if not outright disrespectful, he bullies the students he trains, and tries to crush their motivation in order to keep his spot at the spotlight clean and bright. Already banned and blacklisted in several french promotions, and could quite possibly deserve a ban in every other one."
13826.03.2024
05:36 
yenada wrote about Cornelius Low:
[2.0] "No offense, but I have been quite unimpressed by Low. I have only seen him when he comes to singapore, and he has good hold of the basics of wrestling but every other thing is bland. Very poor / cringe on the mic."
13926.03.2024
05:38 
yenada wrote about John Day:
[2.0] "Completely disagree with other inmate. John Day is not an 8, at all. To each their own, but I really dislike his matches. The way he wrestles and presents himself is as if he's a top heavyweight wrestler but in reality he is one of the smallest guys in the region. I'll give him this, he's a good heel but his promos and antics in the ring are extremely cringe and for me a turn off in any of his matches. I somewhat enjoyed his performance in fight club (butcherman carried) everything else has been mid."
14026.03.2024
17:47 
[2.0] "This is another of revisionist's most absurd fabrication of how "great" Andre the Giant is. Aside from his size and his popularity, there is nothing to be worth praising about his entire wrestling run. He moves very slowly, and his matches are simply mediocre. No matches whatsoever to be recommended as most of his matches are awful and boring to watch. As a babyface, he is simply terrible. Not because of the enormous stature, he would be less interesting as most of the wrestlers in the 70s and 80s. So far, I appreciate his heel run back in 1987 and somewhat a little bit of improvement from his horrendous babyface run. His only notable points of his career are his feud with Killer Khan and Hulk Hogan, which is both mediocre sad to say. Although they considered him a folk hero by some, Andre is not even a decent wrestler as what most of the revisionists and loyalists think. Just be thankful that the landscape of wrestling is truly changed, and we focused on wrestlers who are skilful than just looks and popularity."
14126.03.2024
21:11 
[2.0] "I genuinely feel bad for her. Granted, was she a good wrestler? Absolutely fucking not, even during the days of women's wrestling in America where it was more looks and less about actually wrestling (and that's an understatement). She was a terrible wrestler. But I can tell that she was essentially hired to be laughed at due to her look. I get that was always kind of her job, starting with the Howard Stern show, but I couldn't imagine how that feels to be essentially be a part of a freak show. Rest easy."
14227.03.2024
02:05 
[2.0] "Jim Cornette hasn't provided anything substantial in wrestling for a long ass time and only contributes bigoted, dated ass thoughts for his die hard fan-base of wrestling incels to piggy back off of. Just a lot of weird old manisms that existed during his time when he ran smokey mountain and should've been let go a long time ago. He also has the emotional maturity of an infant which makes for a lot of his meltdowns over stupid stuff like Santino not pretending to be scared of the Boogeyman as an audience member or him theorizing nobody in the AEW locker room tried to have sex with the broom girls? Just very creepy, weird behaviour from him."
14327.03.2024
13:11 
[2.0] "She didnt impress me much. The gear wasnt giving. Her looks arent anything impressive. And her wrestling was ok, but again nothing to write home about. And she's ripping of another flop Lacey Evans with the southern belle gimmick, ugh. No. Improve or get cut after mania."
14427.03.2024
13:20 
[2.0] "From what i've seen on her on TNA she really wasnt anything good/impressive. Basic wrestler with 0 to none charisma and personality"
14503.03.2024
15:49 
crs285 wrote about Shayna Wayne:
[3.0] "Not a huge fan of Shayna Wayne. On the mic she just does not connect to me. Her joining the Patriarchy made no sense to me as she adds very little and when she turned on Edge she telegraphed it. Hopefully if she does want to be in pro wrestling as a manager she works on it as she is very new despite her connections to the business."
14604.03.2024
05:39 
[3.0] "I cant rate her any higher than this. Since she left WWE she wrestled like what 3 times. The Kairi match was extremely slow and boring nothing to write home about + On the 3rd match she injured her self. I see 0 draw in her. Injury prone, difficult to work with/attitude, demands more than she's worth. Dont even let me start on her movie career, b--ch, what career please, having a cameo on some star wars boomer show doesnt make you an actress. Combine that with the fact that she has been "debuting" for half a year. , it makes her look more like Sashalina than a legit boss."
14704.03.2024
16:19 
Larixkh wrote about Abadon:
[3.0] "I admit I don't understand the idea behind Abadon. Maybe in the independent circuit the gimmick works but on television it doesn't work at all and on the contrary gives an extremely ridiculous side especially in a structure like AEW. Unfortunately for her, without being bad, she has an average in-ring performance and is not strong enough to succeed in pulling off anything. I don't doubt his good will and the possibility that in a different circuit, this gimmick could work a little."
14804.03.2024
23:51 
[3.0] "TK and PL book her like she's some cross of Andre the Giant, Roman Reigns, Chyna, and John Lennon. In the limited time she's been in the ring she's been outclassed. She has a phenomenal look and she is stupid-strong, but she wrestles like Nia Jax. I see no reason why she gets treated like some phenom. Bianca should be getting this treatment."
14905.03.2024
03:04 
[3.0] "I think a lot of his early work pre-DX with Diesel is really good. I loved his ladder match with Ramon. But unfortunately a lot of the bad outweighs the good for me as his Attitude Era DX run has never been my favorite, and then going into the 2000s, a lot of his stuff became less and less interesting to me. I will say, the tail end of his career I will always find nostalgia for (09-10) as it was around the time I got into wrestling. But other than that, looking back, Shawn doesn't do it for me. I sadly can't comment on his booking abilities as I hate modern day NXT. His music was pretty neat, and I think his overall presentation was fantastic, especially his WrestleMania 12 entrance. A lot of his personal demons and the way he conducted himself post Montreal Screwjob soured me the most on him."
15005.03.2024
14:14 
[3.0] "WWE seems to have made the same mistake with other people who have a famous name changed to something else. They changed his gimmick, name, and character and now pretty much use him as fodder for the bigger stars in NXT, even though BPJ was a former Rookie of the Year. As Lexis King, he's boring, uninteresting, and just Random Guy A in NXT. He has all the tools, charisma, and skill to be a force, but he's been reduced to a shell of the guy he once was in other places like AEW, as he even was fun in AEW, but now he just has nothing going for him."