54 | Antony Atom | 28.07.2018 | 2092 days | Inwood, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | xx.xx.xxxx | ? | | | |
53 | Max Caster | 16.06.2018 | ? | Inwood, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
52 | Tiberius Sykes | 16.06.2018 | <1 day | Inwood, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
51 | Ishman Martinez | xx.xx.xxxx | ? | | | Matches |
50 | Lance Anoa'i | 01.04.2017 | ? | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
49 | Rocky DiCola | xx.xx.xxxx | ? | | | Matches |
| VACANT | 15.10.2016 | ? | | | |
48 | Butch Hess (2) | 15.10.2016 | <1 day | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
47 | Shorty Smalls | 14.08.2016 | 62 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | 24.07.2016 | 21 days | | | |
46 | Butch Hess | 20.03.2016 | 126 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
45 | LA Starr | 20.11.2015 | 121 days | | | Matches |
44 | Brandon Scott | xx.xx.2014 | ? | | | Matches |
43 | Gustin Uberstud | 22.06.2013 | ? | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | xx.xx.2012 | ? | | | |
42 | Cory Bush | xx.xx.2010 | ? | | | Matches |
41 | Shane Shadows | 11.07.2009 | ? | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
40 | Todd Hill | 26.01.2008 | 532 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | 13 | Matches |
| VACANT | xx.01.2008 | ? | | | |
39 | Headshrinker Samu (5) | 30.06.2007 | ? | Cambridge, Maryland, USA | 12 | Matches |
| VACANT | 04.06.2007 | 26 days | | 11 | |
38 | Gangrel | 25.05.2007 | 10 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
37 | Leslie Leatherman (4) | 31.03.2007 | 55 days | Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
36 | Gutterboy (3) | 20.05.2006 | 315 days | Newville, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
35 | John Rambo (7) | 17.12.2005 | 154 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
34 | Gutterboy (2) | 13.08.2005 | 126 days | Newville, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
33 | Jason Static | 21.05.2005 | 84 days | Newville, Pennsylvania, USA | 10 | Matches |
32 | Genesis | 19.03.2005 | 63 days | Newville, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
31 | Headshrinker Samu (4) | 09.10.2004 | 161 days | USA | 9 | Matches |
| VACANT | 07.10.2004 | 2 days | | | |
30 | Snatch Haggis | 18.09.2004 | 19 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
29 | Super Destroyer | 17.07.2004 | 63 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
28 | OGB | 08.07.2004 | 9 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
27 | Dorian Deville | 03.07.2004 | 5 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
26 | The Pirate Of The Caribbean | 26.06.2004 | 7 days | Newville, Pennsylvania, USA | 8 | Matches |
| VACANT | 18.06.2004 | 8 days | | 7 | |
25 | Headshrinker Samu (3) | 18.06.2004 | <1 day | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
24 | Leslie Leatherman (3) | 08.05.2004 | 41 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
23 | Headshrinker Samu (2) | 14.02.2004 | 84 days | Blue Ridge Summit, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
22 | Leslie Leatherman (2) | 24.01.2004 | 21 days | Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
21 | The Patriot | 23.01.2004 | 1 day | Newville, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
20 | Leslie Leatherman | 01.11.2003 | 83 days | Blue Ridge Summit, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
19 | Morgus The Maniac | 19.07.2003 | 105 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
18 | Aidiean | 24.05.2003 | 56 days | Blue Ridge Summit, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
17 | Headshrinker Samu (2) | 26.04.2003 | 28 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
16 | Corporal Punishment | 12.04.2003 | 14 days | Keyser, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
15 | Headshrinker Samu | 08.02.2003 | 63 days | Greencastle, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
14 | Jake Davis | 11.01.2003 | 28 days | Martinsburg, West Virginia, USA | | Matches |
13 | John Rambo (6) | 20.04.2002 | 266 days | Bainbridge Township, Ohio, USA | | Matches |
12 | Spazman Anthony (3) | 15.01.2002 | 95 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
11 | John Rambo (5) | 26.06.2001 | 203 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
10 | Spazman Anthony (2) | 29.03.2001 | 89 days | Cumberland, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
9 | Jimmy Snuka | 01.02.2001 | 56 days | Frederick, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
8 | Spazman Anthony | 29.12.2000 | 34 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | 6 | Matches |
| VACANT | 13.12.2000 | 16 days | | 5 | |
7 | John Rambo (4) | 13.05.1999 | 580 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
6 | Gutterboy | 22.04.1999 | 21 days | Waynesboro, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
5 | John Rambo (3) | xx.xx.1997 | ? | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | 4 | Matches |
| VACANT | 23.08.1996 | ? | | 3 | |
4 | Neil Superior | xx.11.1991 | ? | USA | 2 | Matches |
| VACANT | xx.11.1991 | ? | | | |
3 | John Rambo (2) | 23.10.1991 | ? | Mangilao, Guam, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | 22.10.1991 | 1 day | | | |
2 | Cactus Jack | 22.10.1991 | <1 day | Guam, USA | | Matches |
1 | John Rambo | 23.03.1989 | 943 days | Elk Garden, West Virginia, USA | 1 | Matches |